The Archive · 1933

Mustard and Cross

eh, 18

The public figure who at no time has desired top———summary power for supp) of newspaper criticism must be tire," Actors—not to mention actresses—profess that they: wish critics to write the truth but they are apt to talk of pistols if the truth should dilate on professional incompetence. There was once a famous prima donna whose maid was charged with the duty of withholding all newspapers which. gave unfavourable accounts of her mistress's latest portrayal, sometimes extraordinary to find how rapidly a critic can fall from grace. On Monday hi finds blemishes in A's mortal enemy: A discerns a Daniel come to judgment. On Tuesda, he criticises A, lightly perhaps but palpably; A feels that that critic's extermination would be Deneficial to mankind. This impatience with criticism is usually accompanied by a fervent affirmation of belief in the freedom of the Press and in the healthiness of independent expression of views on public affairs; merely indicates that the particular critic is beyond the pale, because of his malice, lack of training or other" patently noisome disability. Politicians lean on journalists; but at one time or another most politicians could point to journalists of. whose decease they would hear, with equanimity, The very green politician sends out a smoke screen by accusing the news-Papers generally of inaccuracy. He thinks it may come in handy when he has to explain away an awkward utterance. So, until ho becomes experienced, a poli cian may make the fatal remark that he has been "'misreported.' He forgets, what his leaders always remember, namely that to the journalist the politician often owes the conversion of an awkward utterance into a safe ambiguity. Mr. Lloyd George, who was then old enough to know better, once daringly tried to extricate himself from a dilemma at the expense of a reporter. His complete exposure stands on record as a warning to, lesser men.

The Press is not perfect but in the matter of recording events and sayings it is an, expert machine which is likely to be more accurate than the talented amateur, Let those who find abuse of the fidelity of press-reporting a congenial topic, test for themselves the accounts given in the social circle of a particular event of the moment. They will be surprised at the variety of the versions presented. Most people have played at the game of passing a message from mouth to mouth end have wondered at the discrepancy between the alpha and omega of that simple enterprise. This, of course, does not imply a complete absence from journalism of the imps of malice, uncharitableness, and mendacity. In the handling of news to-day the tried news editor must often wax wroth as he endea-yours to climate the obvious propaganda and the obvious inaccuracies from the stream of material placed at his disposal. His success is measured by the extent to which the coy but gracious presence of truth is eventually revealed on the print. ed page by his direction. He will probably admit that even the inaccuracies have their uses. [They tend to throw up in relief the realities of the situation, They provide a sound safeguard of impartiality because, were it not for their attempted exploitation of a subject, the unbiassed truth might not find credence or, even, attention. So, provided the" main policy of sound journalism is to instruct faithfully and fearlessly, the eccentricities of the other sort matter little. The best check on untruth is still the truth rather principle to which harassed Governments would do well to adhere with greater confidence than some of them appear to No country in the to-day can, apparently, dispense with control of press criticism in some form or other, in greater or less degree. But countries, which desire to put themselves on the best possible: terms with the rest of the world, endeavour to limit control within the framework of legal definition. They avoid that arbitrary system which in certain countries takes the form of extreme censorship unaccountable to, judicial ruling.

Here in China the formulation of a press policy" is still indefinite, although certain regulations have been tentatively put forward. The Government rightly has resented the attempt by Japanese authorities to impose on China that rigorous and unreasoning censorship which to-day! quite impossible to define Japanese public opinion with certainty. It has probably! been realised that the tendency' of the Chinese Government a few years ago to encourage direct action against critics fadjudged_to be unfriendly reacted unfavourably against China. Significant is it that in his latest} book, Mr. J. O. P. Bland makes by no means ineffective play with the fact that at one time drastic measures were proposed in thi regard. At this time of crisis when China can ask for nothing better than the presentation to the world of every fact and every opinion on her affairs, it) would be highly impolitic to 4 colour to the view that criticism were resented and, being resented, suppressed. It is pertinent' to offer this advice for of late: there have been disturbing signs of an uncertainty of policy in Nanking. Chinese journalists are exceedingly anxious concerning the recent murder of the correspondent of the "China Times"—an outrage which is said to have a sinister import. The execution of the manager. of a newspaper in Chekiang at the bidding of the Provincial Gov-_ ernor was another symptom of the same malady. Here in Shanghai the refusal of postal facilities to the "Far Eastern Review" has been ai error in facties. "It were fat better to [permit that journal which, after all, has a definite reputation, to circulate freely and thus involun-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account