The Archive · 1928

Decision of the Court

Tu' dismissing the ° charge his Worship reviewed the evidence at great length and said it was a very trivial ease concerning a child: and 'a broken vase. He could not agree that Mr. Maguire had obstructed M. Leon Henri in the course of his In the charge room, Mr. content to concur. tated in his evidence quite familiar with the rules concerning the issue of warrants und yet the warrant was not countersigned by an officer of H. M. Court. 'M. Henri had called at the British Consulate and had been directed by. a municipal police officer to the Assersor's room but the Assessor was out.

1 do not know why M, Henri did not come to see me," continued his Worship, "I could have given him the endorsement he req There is no doubt that if M. Henri had adopted the: correct procedure, ho could have obtained a proper endorsement." The following day, M. Hern sent a Chinese detective. to: the Consulate for the endorsement of an. offeial. He saw Mr. Burdett who referred him to the Senior Consul. It was clear that] Mr. Burdett was under the impression that the Senior Consul's signature. was necessary as he thought that the parties involved, resided in the International Settlement and so referred the matter to the Ame can Consulate. " If. the complainant is, French and the defendant Chi-neve, both residing in the International Settlement, a warrant, would: have to bear the signature the Senior Consul: and' the.defendant would subsequently appear in: the Provisional: Court. There was nothing in the warrant before the Court to show that it was required for execution on: Britisty property, apart from the address Route Pere: Robert in. Chinese characters which did not give any information.

On the.strength of that warrant, continued his Worship, M.. Henri arrested the boy.. Mr. Maguize took exception to. the validity, of the: warrant and regarding what transpired after, there was a conflict of evidence. M. Henri said that Mr.

Maguire put his hand on his chest and pushed him. Mr. Maguire stated that he placed his hand on arm and told M." Hem Maguire also laid a hand on M. Henri.

'The defendant bank was represchted by Mr. C. &. Franklin, who subsequently appealed against the decision' rendered. The amount involved was Mex, $500,000 and concerned a deposit in the bank at Harbin in the int names of the plaintiff company and Messrs, Beckman, Linden & Ca,, of San Francisco, The case arose over the bank's refusal to. pay out] instead:

The Use of Handeutts the money: except on the: signatures! of both parties. regard to the handcuffing: of 'Mr. Maguire, his Worship said' that handcuffs. were ordinarily used in dealing with dangerous and violent jcritninals, "Edo not think, he. remarked, "'that any police officer in normal frame of mind would adopt that' method in a.case like this, and I do not think that even if Mf Henri thought Mr. Maguire looked menacing: and angry,, there was sufficient reason to restrain him by: handenfing." It was-possible, how-tin. Henri construed Mi hand-raising tention to attack him, On the evidence before him, continued his Worship, he had come to the conclusion that no assault on M, Henri had taken place. Mr. Maguire's objection to the boy being detained id not constitute obstruction and, after all, it was very reasonable objection. It was not necessary for him, concluded his Worship, to come to a decision regarding whether or not the we rant was a legal document. He would refrain from making a decision on that point as the matter was sub judice in another Court. The.case would be dismissed.

Mr. Newman asked that! -cosbs be awarded against the -French Tpotiee, but his Worship ruled that fs he had no jarisdietion over that body, he could not-make an order fand. "therefore "Mr. Newman's application must be: refused.

This is the first tite that Judge Purdy-has had.a decision reversed.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account