The Archive · 1931

INDIAN CONFERENCE

Jan, Mr. Ramsay MacDonald and Lord Sankey have done remarkably well to bring the Indian Conference smoothly along thy line of sensible discussion of the main issues involved in the forging of a constitution for India. They cannot be blamed for the delay which has occurred ever since the pivotal obstacle to ready agreement began to stand stark and unshakable i its traditional stubbornness. will have been noted that the Conference which had to be summoned with so negligent an appearance of reliance on the Simon Report in order to pla: cate the left-wing section 0: British Indian politicians, has come to unanimous findings in close confirmation of the Simon Commission's recommendations.

It has been agreed' that Burm: shall be separated from India and that Federation shall be the form of the new Constitution includ agu-Chelmsford Constitution the whole of the Indian Empire, or, in other words, British India and the Indian States. But where the Simon Commission found it impossible to give unreserved approval to the idea that the self-government prin. ciple could be rapidly advanced in India, there exactly has the Conference found, so far, its most formidable difficulty. The!

Commission said "We regret that an_sccommodation between the Moslems and Hindus has not yet been reached, The considerations mentioned in paragraph 231 of the Montagu-Chelmsford Report still hold. If an agreed solution is not forthcoming, there remains "a very serious hindrance to the self-governing principle." But' no third party, however friendly and disinterested, can do what the two communities' might ce-operate doing for themselves by mutual agreement. In the absence of such agreement, we are compel to assume, in reference to thi matter, a°continuance of separate communal electorates."

Stimulated by the knowles that failure to come to an agree! ment would be an unmistakable refutation of the pretensions which they had put, forward, Indian politicians have "had! every incentive to waive prejudice, to make compromises and to show tolerance. Yet even la so favourable an atmosphere of goodwill, they have still to find the solution. Thus recent history of abortive conference after abortive conference on the subject of Hindu-Moslem unity is being repeated. To do Mr. Gandhi justice he long ago foresaw the need for breaking down this bar to political progress. His Hindu-Moslem unity. firm while it lasted; it was however, based on a lie and on hatred—of the British. The re+ sult was that Mr. Mahomed Alt, his coadjutor of those days, had to break away later for he per ceived the insecurity of the pact. Hindu-Moslem unity can be tisfactorily created on no illus sions, on no unrealities. Tha effect of the working of the reformed constitution with its promise of more rapid Indianization of the administration has indeed been to stir up the evil spirit of discord. Distrust of each other has led the two communities to maneuvre for favourable political points of vant+ age. This has led to everwiden: ing rifts and friction on a unprecedented in modern Indian history. From it has directly come the impetus given to dis orderly revolutionism in the face of visibly weakened authority, It is easy to moralize over this impasse. The mere fact however, that it seems at the moment to persist should give rise to much regret, It will ime pose a check on the scheme for stabilization of political pro gress. It must necessarily discount many of the successes—~=m gained at the Conference unless, by some means or other, its worwt@) features can be mitigated. The British Government can do noth ing to abolish communal elec torates without the support of all parties concerned. They caw however, justifiably proceed 1 meet the wishes of the Moslems of the North-West Frontier Province in regard to the adminis" tration of that area in which the Hindu minority is negligible. They might even consider seriously the separation of Sind from Bombay. With those two major points in the protection of Moslem interests established, it is conceivable that the solu. tion of the electoral issue might follow at some later date. The really serious danger is that the Conference will separate without giving the delegates from British India a substantial case for justification of their journey to England. The Indian Princess who have played so great part in the Conference, are in the fortunate position of being able to count on acceptance in their States of engagements entered into in London. The Brit-sh Indian representatives on the other hand have come with severely limited status. Unlesé they can show spectacular rev sults they are certainly bound to be exposed to all odium of mass repudiation and contumely fiercely directed by Congress implacables. The fact that they could not honourably lend themtselves in London to, the brazening out of untenable claims will g0 for nothing. They will be put to great straits and it will take much strength of mind—to say nothing of patient and me telligent political organization—to consolidate their position, This seems to be the point a which the Conference " stands)", now that it has reached what ought to be its " concluding phases, Tris not a cheerful poate.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account