This appears to us to have been sufficient to account for the collision, and at the same time to account for the opinion of those on board the Han Wo that she had "starboarded" her helm and altered her course to port at the moment of the collision. No doubt the Han Wo and the first line of lighters passed safely, for the reason that the cannon off the bank did not take effect till just after they passed, and was just in time to be struck by the Jast lighter. The force of the collision naturally drove the Teh Hsing full on the hank, as we have heard in evidence.
We are also of opinion that the Han Wo was not giving sufficient allowance of space to allow her tow of lighters to pass the Teh Hsing without risk of accident. She had in tow three lighters abreast each other, measuring 26-ft. wide. According to the evidence of the Han Wo, she was in the middle of the river, but, as has already been pointed out, it was a dark and misty night and in our opinion she must have been nearer the Teh Hsing than she thought she was. That thinking she was in the middle of the river she considered she had given plenty of room, but as a matter of fact she was much nearer the left bank. This supposition is supported by the statement of those on board the Teh Hsing, who state that they thought she was coming dangerously near them and caused them to go somewhat closer to the bank. Consequently both ships were to blame—the Teh Hsing for steering too near to the bank, causing her to sheer off the mud, and the Han Wo for not giving sufficient space in passing to safeguard against accident or slight miscalculation.
The night, as I have already said, was dark and misty, and one witness says drizzling rain." It would consequently be difficult for all the persons concerned to give -absolutely definite and. reliable statements as to distances, etc., but we think that all the witnesses on both sides have given the best and most truthful evidence, and ac-
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.