On the face of it such a ons-sided arrangement seems im able, Agreements for contingent fees are not uncommon and they are now yalid in all American jurisdictions at least. But we have never known of one which left entirely uncertain the amount to be realized in case the contingency should occur.
The preponderance of the evidence then is with plaintiffs and as witnesses their interest~ is no greater than defendant's. is preponderance is strengthened by the inherent probabilities of the case for it seems to us wholly improbable that lawyers of ordinary prudence would pledge their services for an indefinite period without compensation in one contingency and with entire uncertainty as to the amount of compensation in the other contingency. must find that the agreement was as alleged aad testified to by plaintiffs.
The latter likewise allege that the amount fixed in the agreement, viz., 20 per cent, was a reasonable one and in this we think they are also supported by the evidence. The counsel whom defendant subsequently employed was called by him as a witness and testified that had he conducted the case alone he would have considered as a redgpnable fee Tls. 2,000 which is: not much more than plaintiff now claim. We do not see that the employment of additional, counsel without their suggestion or knowledge should be allowed to reduce their compensation. Their services were at defendant's disposal exactly the same as before and there seems to have been no thought of terminating them. The case would have been different had plaintiffs asked for another attorney or had defendant sought then to dispense with their services, paying them for what had been rendered.> But since they continued without change of status there would seem to be no reason for reducing their compensation because defendant saw fit to employ another to ce-operate with them.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.