The Archive · 1922

CHILD LABOUR

To the Editor of the "Norra-Cuina Datty News."

Sir,—I have read with interest Mrs. MacGillivray's letter in your Friday's issue, and beg to sav that I am in entire agreement with the views expressed. It is indeed very gratifying to see a foreign gentleman like Dr. MacGillivray so enthusiastic in the welfare of another nation, and I do not see any reason why we should consider his suggestions at all ins practicable. China of to-day,, as we are all aware, is the scene of all sorts of troubles, political and social; and of these social troubles child labour is one. If we are unable to assist in the bettering of the political conditions, we ought at least to perform our respective parts to solve the social difficulties. In this respect, Mrs. MacGillivray's letter is not only a challenge to the local churches and clubs, but assuredly a good piece of advice to the Chinese public.

As to the mills to which she refers in particular, I would assure her that still more serious cases than these may be found in the semi-adults (shall I call them so?) pulling ricshas in the Chinese districts. I am a Chinese, but I do not wish to hide Chinese faults because I ama Chinese. At any rat>, we consider the suggestion of giving child labourers half-day education and half-day work very advisable, if only the mill-owners have enough sense of duty and sacrifice to carry it out.

I am, ete., C. S. Waxe, Shanghai, Dee. 2, 1922.

To the Editor of the "Nonrru-Curya Dairy News."

Stmr,—The question of the education of the Chinese lower classes is one of great importance and the query arises:—Does atr Municipal responsibility end with supporting a few high class Chinese schools? A large part of our revenue comes from taxing these people, besides which there are benefits such as band, parks, ete. in which they do not. share, in respect to which we might spend more on their education. Ft is obvious that the wages paid to industrial workers, as well as to much of the labour employed by ow very Council is not sufficient to keep them and at the same time pay for educating their children: indeed it is often admitted by those responsible that it is necessary for every member of a family no matter how young to work in order to provide the barest living. If this is so, then the responsibility for their education must rest either with their employment or with the community. Tf, as it is said, there is no Chinese Government support' for schools inside the Settlement, then it would seem that the duty falls on the Council. Our education system is under consideration just now and it may be found necessary to modify it into some form of giving grants, grants based on the tax returns of the different groups of nationals, and let them conduct their own schools. Similar grants night be made to a Chinese Educational Committee whic would be responsible to the Council that the money was used to the best advantage for all and would cover the ground now lacking, or be supplemented till it could. do so from their side. There is little doubt but that we could rely on our Chinese friends for hearty support in any scheme where education is concerned and hereby we might remove one of the great difficulties in the way of remedying the evils of child labour. I an, ete., F. 0. R. Warp.

shanghai, Dec. 5, 1922.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account