The Archive · 1922

What Really Happened

The writer of this letter happened to be staying in the garrison headquarters of the 3rd Division a few miles from the city of Loyanz when Dr. Schurman and his party arrived there and was present at all of the interviews with Wu Pei-fu and his advisers and staff officers. The conversations are very clear in his memory.

Dr. Schurman did not go te Loyang to take up the question of the captured missionaries with General Wu Pei-fu. This does not come within the functions of a minister plenipotentiary. He is not expected to take up such issues directly with provincial authori ties, but through the Chinese Government, leaving such negotiations as ave necessary to the local consular authorities. Upon his arrival in Loyang, however, Dr Schurman was received by General Wu Pei-fu and was lodged in the "palace" among the "gardens and grounds" which, according to the carried from Mien Chih I{sien, are for the gratification of the Manchu princess, and are now overrun with the' General's ladies, according to the same account. Having been brought in such close contact with the most powerful military figure in the neighbourhood and having just consulted with the American Consul-General in Hankow and with missionaries from Honan at the same port, Dr.

churman felt it his duty to discuss the bandit situation with General Wu and to learn from him what he or his military subordinates proposed to do. The actual conversation took place after dinner on the evening of Saturday, October 28. The writer has not had permission from either Dr. Schurman or General Wu to publish what was actually said, but feels that after the absurd statement that they agreed that the missionaries '"'must learn fo accept all the risks involved" he is warranted in giving an outline of what was said without specific licence from the principals in the conversation.

Prior to the dinner the writer asked General Wu's chief political adviser to tell General Wu that Dr. Schurman wanted to discuss the plight of the captured missionaries, whereupon General Wu suggested that we discuss it at dinner. One hundred and fifty officers were present at the dinner, however, and the occasion demanded so much discussion of other topics that the bandit situation did not come up.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account