The Archive · 1931

An Insurance Episode

Jan. 17. here are many episodes the fall facts of which seldom come "to light even though public attention may be drayon to them "by any of those accidents which "the paraphernalia of elviliz: tion are liable to cause. The "tale of the loss of the s.s. Ping-"gu was recorded at the time in the columns of the "North: 'China Daily News." Briefly the "atory was this: Shortly after Aeaving Tehang on the morning of February il, the ship struck rock in' the' Kungelingtang, "Rapids and remained in that unhappy position until, under the orders of the Customs authorities a month later she "was blown up in order to keep Mine river clear for navigation purposes. Very shortly utter the stranding local sampan-men "came out to the ship, literally taking possession of her. Pashengers and crew: were taken "ashore at highly "extortionate #¥ates after being relieved of odd 'wAlnables and personal effects, Jana then the hours which follow-"ed were spent in looting any-"thing in the ship's equipment "and furnishings which could yehdily be removed. The came "tight fire broke out on the ship the looters were compelled Jeave her. When visited the "following afternoon she was still smoking, everything above }water line including the forward ween decks being practically seestroyed by tne sre, Her holds, however, with the main part of the cargo seem to have been still "Aptact, but during the weeks Which followed it. disappeared, {Mhanke to the assiduous attention of bands of pirates who

Yess position of the ship to jfook advantage of the help-"inaugurate a systematic cam iyaign of looting, "lid when SGmally the ship was blown up Fas every vestige hid fishppeared. This was iblishbyt the reports received from the salvage authorities who visited the ship and from other sources, and, incidentally, by the '4éreumstance that after the ship *was blown up there was not a wign'of debris in the water to "'$hdicate that the looters had not)

"tntide a clean job of'it. In fact, "Wiewed entirely from a technical point of view, the bandits' "salvage" work could be assessed "asipresenting a high standard of eficiency.

But the journey of a ship, even

cargo, is not a matter be-river Yangtsze, laden *Riveen the' ship herself, the captain, and such casual strang-vets as' pirates and the like. "Phere' are important' ceremonies "Whictt have to be arranged by the prudent owner' of the ship Wid "by the shippers of the argo, There is the matter, for instance of "insurance. In this articular episode insurance layed a very interesting part. "The policies under which pr Meally all the cargo was in-'Wuyed: covered: the' usual marine tighs—stranding, sinking, fire ind collision—but they' also Shohided a "clause "expressly chiding losses due' to' piracy.

is "fause, it "seems hard ly*hecessary "to explain, zheant what the insured~ paid a lower premium than' they would otherwise have "had -to pay if they! contemplated asking for cover against -piracy. The insured. and the insurers, h wever, did not agree in the inter pretation of the loss which occurred to the Pingfu. In the eyes of the insurers the loss of the cargo was in fact due to piracy. The other side maintained that the loss was a direct consequence of the stranding. English insurance law has a very well-known doctrine, which is consistently applied arriving at decisions on this subject. That doctrine is known as the doctrine of cause prozima, which means that the insured are covered against loss which directly accrues from risks covered by the policy. In this case it was notorious that systematic looting had occurred. It was on record that a large number of sampans were engaged for several days afterwards in removing bales from the ship, and, in fact, the merry game of making hay while the sun shone was proceeding in the rapids of Kungc-ling-tan. Later some of the profiteers in this adventure were chuckling at the cheapness with which they were able to buy piece-goods bearing very reputable marks. All the companies concerned repudiated liability and so far no action whatever has been taken against the British: and: American Companies who carried: most of the insurance, but one shipper has sued a German company in the Provisional Court, "and the Court's decision supported the insured's view that the loss was due directly to stranding

the policy. and ys therefore covered by The importance of the case is clear when it is realized that]

China has no marine insurance law, but in the absence of any indication to the contrary it has generally been considered that) "English law and usage" applies, and most companies' policies dear a specific clause to that! effect. Whatever may be the 'exact outcome of the application of Chinese equity in this case, there can be no possible doubt that if the' principles of English law and usage were invoked—and they are recognized as a valuable guide throughout the world—the contention of the insurers would be upheld. To quote a recognized organ of the British shipping industry, the judgment shows a marked divergence from British prineiples in regard to what constitutes' piracy or theft, and as to what is "a necessary and protimate cause of loss." The High Court of Kiangsu, which gave a decision in favour of the insured, took-its stand on the ground that if the ship had not been stranded the robbery could not have occurred, and therefore there was a direct relationship of cause and effect between the stranding and the robbery. The Couit went on to say that whether an insurance company: should be held liable for losses depended entirely upon whether the loss was one insured against) and did not depend upon when ther the loss could have been avoided -or not. Here again is a doctrine to which strong. exception would-be taken by British experts in insurance law. The axiomatic "dictum that a contract of; insurance is a contract of indeninity is in clear danger of being ignored in circumstances of this kind, for when a ship in the plight of the Pingfu is subjected to leisurely' but wholesale robbery, without let or hindrance, itie obvious that opportunities "are". given gravely to prejudice the position of the insurer beyond his capacity to'prevent. It is possible that'this ease may be carried farther, but at this stage /tio'harm ean'be done by draw-fig attention' to the considered

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account