The Archive · 1931

The Ethics of Relief

Feb. 6.

Although it is evident that President Hoover is taking a big political risk in resisting the Proposal for the grant of Go ernment funds on a large scale to deal with the present economic distress in America, his stand is undoubtedly based on sound principles for statesmanship. That, perhaps is cold comfort for the Congressman or Senator who has a_ vivid sense of the anxiety now felt in the country. "It naturally will be used to the full extent by the President's political opponents to discredit his position. On January 17 the Senate passed an amendment to the Department of the Interior Appropriation Bill] Ps providing G§25,000,000 for the immediate purchase of food. In those quarters of the Administration's ranks where less emphasis is laid on economic principles and more on politi cal strategy, this figure was regarded asthe price which would have to be paid to avoid further difficulties. The conviction was strengthened by the knowledge that other proposals were in train by Senators for the introduction of Bills ostensibly for the development of public works, but in reality designed to afford relief to the and hungry, such circumstances the President's endeavour to show that the situation is not as desperate as these proposals must naturally inflame highly sensitive public opinion. The dity of the political economist often evokes impatience when it amounts to a refusal to take what appears to be a short cut out of a serious financial dilemma. Tt remains. to be seen whether President Hoover is strong enough to resist the pressure, which shows signs of diminishing. It must be admitted, however, that his attitude is strengthened by the authoritative assertion of the Chairman of the American Red Gross to the effect that yoluntary funds can cope adequately with the -existing situation, England at the moment is bitter= ly regretting the tendency of a Government to use public funds for the direct mitigation distress. The Unemploymer Insurance Act, into the working of which a Royal Commission is now enquiring, has facilitated the invasion of the highly speculative sphere of poor relief by machinery designed originally to deal scientifically with a problem which could be: actuarily defined. The result has been that, actuarial considerations having gone by the board, the country is faced with a growing expenditure with which only the purse. of Fortunatus could be expected adequately to deal. No doubt the Royal Commission will recommend the necessary corrective fo this lapse from the recognized canons of public finance. The violation of the same principle is what Presideat Hoover obviously fears.

No one would deny" that in certain circumstances State relief in times of unexpected necessity is desirable and com mendable, Perhaps the classic example is to be found in the Indian Famine Code, which has been taken as a model for other countries with some success. But the essence of the Famine Ti n its strict adminis-highly centralized bureaucracy and its provision of lief on very rigorously defined lines. The use of the word "famine" is in reality misleading. It would be more accurate nowa-to apply the term "unemployment," and therefore the analogy has special bearing on the situation which President Hoover is endeavouring to handle, There can be no doubt that in a country so progress America and so well-equipped for the development of national movements the best way of exercising purely philan-tropic effort is by means of agencies. The State can do its share by pushing ow which otherwise been hung up, bj giving facilities for the waif conduct of a campaign against distress, but it should be chary of assuming direct financial responsibility for relief in itself, When a country is faced with an emergency of the character which the messages from American suggest the danger of resources being frittered away by the misdirected employment of emergency State machinery considerable, When there exists, as in the Red Cros organization, an agency which, although voluntary in. its basis, has actually the moral standing of a national body, it would seem that there is the ideal instru-mont for relief judiciously and adequately directed to the purpose required. After all, sident Hoover's own record shows that he can speak with special authority on this subject, and it will indeed be prising in spite of his political opponents' strenuous efforts to credit him, he will not be able to carry the country with him at this critical juncture. There can be mo blinking the fact that at the moment the American people are going through a very trying period. But it would be derogatory to the genius of the nation and, in all probability, am exaggeration of passing phases, if it'were not pointed out that this present depression is in ne small measure a natural reaction to which a definite term can be fixed. In other words, there is sufficient vigour in American commerce and there is sufficient

selves for an early recovery Vitality, inthe people them-be achieved. bao

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account