Enough has been said in the argument to show that the new evidence is directed to the: existence of a contract to restore five pictures, for the loss of which the jury awarded the plaintiff $600 damages. It is obvious from the cross-examination of Krukoff that this matter was in the minds of the defendant and his counsel at the trial: even the existence of the pictures at all was the subject of a question; and the plaintiffs were asked before trial to produce the pictures and stated they were unable to do so. The contract was supported by the production of two letters on the subject of those pictures from one Dukelsky: no objection was taken to the production of these letters and Dukelsky was not called as a witness. The letters do not seem to have been produced before trial to the defendant's counsel, buf the nature of the contract was set out with considerable particularity in the statement of claim, and all inquiry could have been made about it from that. It seems to me clear that assuming the new evidence could destroy that item of damage, it could hardly be said to be con-elusive as to the rest of the case.
In order, however, to do_no injustice 1m this matter, I have looked at the affidavit of Vladimir Evdokimoff which was sworn in other proceedings in this action, and was sought to be used by the appellant on this application. It was sworn on January 8, 1923—the trial was only concluded on December 19, 1922; and is to the effect that no such pictures as were referred to in the evidence were in the Russian National Library at the material dates. Even that does
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.