Saturday Judge Lobingier delivered his reserved decision in the case of Way Cheong & Ca., Ld. the Methodist Episcopal Church {South Mission. Plaintiffs brought an action to foreclose a mechanic's lien alleged to have been attached to a building owned by the principal defendant and partially erected under contract with it by another defendant to whom plaintiff furnished certain material and labour which were used in the construction of the "building.
Judgment was for defendants with costs; Judge Lobingier said that the parties had entered into a stipulation as to the facts, from which it appeared that the second defendant abandoned his contract of construction before the same was completed. At the time the Stewart-Crane Ca., Ince. breached and abandoned the said contract as aforesaid, the defendant had paid to Stewart-Crane Ca., Inc. all and more than was due the said Stewart-Crane Ca, Inc, and that at the time the notice of lien alleged in paragraph 8 of said complaint was filed there was no amount due, owing or payable under said contract by defendant to the said Stewart-Crane Ca., Me.
Notwithstanding such admission plaintiff alleged a lien on the entire building and grounds and asked for a sale thereof to satisfy its claim. Under the latest Act of Congress prevailing in the jurisdiction, however, such liens were "Yimited to the amount to become due to the original contractor." It would be seen that there was nothing so due at the time of plaintiff's notice of lien.
Plaintiff's counsel, however, invoked an earlier Act under which it was claimed that the lien should be satisfied notwithstanding there was nothing due from the contractor. But the time honoured rule in applying conflicting legislation is that the later prevails.
To the objection that the later Act is inapplicable because it required the filing of the lien la the office of "the Clerk of the Supreme Court of the District,"
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.