principal party in an action in the Shanghai Provisional Court was uphold by Judge Ying in that Court last week, in connection with the case brought by them against 'Messrs, 8, Heimann & Ca., a Polish firm, in which they claimed Ts, 100,- 000,' the alleged value of 536'bales see goods said to have been held rust for them under delivery in defendants' godowns. Plaintiffs alleged that, following the suspension of business by various Soviet institutions in China, defen. dants refused to return the goods to them.
Action was brought by plaintiffs Ehrough Messes. Musso, Fischer Wilhelm, liquidators, and the ques-arose as to whether they were a state institution of the Uniow of Soviet Socialist Republics and whether they could: ba party to the action. Defendants contended that they could not as the Soviet Government was not recognized by the National Government of China, The Decision Judge Ying's decision roads:—'The defendants' arguments has the following four important points:
1—That though plaintiits alleged that they are a limited company they have not proved that they are limited company or company of ind.
That the order of the National Government of December, 1927, was enforced to put an end to the C munist propaganda disseminating from Soviet institutions which were consequently ordered to be closed and that the Syndicate was evident-Ly one of those institutions.
3—That the powers of attorney given to agents of the Syndicate here 1926 and 1927 stipulated that eon-tracts entered by. them should be first approved by t of Russian Commercial Committee in China and also setting, out that dai from such contracts could only. be made direct to the Syndicate, that claimants must waive the right to claim from the U.S.S.R, oF the commercial committee, and the People's Supreme Economic Contmittec te Which the Syndicate belonged or other state institutions of the USSR.
What has to be settled first this case is whether or not the Syndicate can be a party to the action, 'Their hong-name was All Union' Textile Syndicate, Syndicate means an association of commercial enterprises. In plaintiffs! ease it means a society constituting numer rows persons in the textile trade in partnership.
'The Plaintiffs' Articles The defendants contended that iff had not proved that they a limited liability company. tis, however, have produced thole articles of association in which it was stated that at their inception on February 28, 1918, their fixed capital was. pre-war roubles 20,- (000,000 consisting of 10,000 shares of 2,000 roubles each and that at a meeting of shareholders in April 25, 1925, it was decided to change the marital to roubles 50,000,000 which was approved by the Supreme Economic Council of the USSR. On June 2, 1925, partners of the Syndicate consisted of 42 firms deal-me in raw materials, 21 cotton weaving factories, eight hemp weave ing factories, one underwear factory, eight silk, woollen and weaving factories, a silk weaving factory and other factories.
Phe second point raised by the defendants was that plaintiffs were Soviet state institution because the National Government had ordered them to suspend operations. Th National Government measure was policy of protection during a time
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.