The Archive · 1923

A Case of Illegal

TAXATION

Mar. 29, Otr attention has been called to an important case of illegal provincial taxation, which vividly illustrates the flimsiness of any agreement made with the Peking Government for the abolition of likin in return for a surtax on the Customs dues. To understand the position, it is necessary to recall certain broad facts of bygone history. Every merchant is familiar with the long-standing dispute over transit passes and the protection they afford. About the year 1914 the Diplomatic Body accepted the view that these passes exempted the goods for which they are issued from all further taxation.

The Chinese, however, steadily maintain that this exemption applies only to the point of destination named in the pass. It would take too long to go into the whole history of the controwersy. But in the year 1921 the big tobacco companies succeeded in making an agreement with Peking under which the payment by them of certain taxes at the port of shipment should free their cigarettes, whether imported or made in China, from any further impost. Certain scales of taxation were laid down in the agreement, according to the quality of the cigarettes, payment was made to Peking and the trade went forward.

That there could be no possible doubt as to the meaning of the agreement and its applicability all through China, is. amply shown in the following clause Cigarettes transported and sold by the Company after having paid Inland Tax and Factory Tax, being accompanied by Tax Passes and bearing the Revenue Stamps, shall be exempt from all likin taxes, and all kinds of duties, taxes, etc., throughout the different Provinces. In the event of other taxes being imposed on goods that have already paid Inland Tax and Factory Tax, the Company may upon producing receipts for such payments deduct the amount paid from the taxes that should thereafter be paid, but Business and Licence Taxes levied on shops are not within this category. 7

There is no moral doubt that Peking got the provinces to assent to this agreement by promising them their share of the taxes paid on the cigarettes that went within their borders. And the agreement has worked perfectly well until a few weeks ago,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account