Mr. Maitland objected to the introduction of these reports, as a matter of public policy.
On looking through the reports, his Worship said he was inclined to admit them, Mr. Maitland—These are official reports made in the course of his duty by an inferior officer to a superior. Defendant had no option but to make the first two; he could not refuse.
Commenting on a case quoted by Mr. Maitland, his Worship observed that it only went so far as to say that if the head of a department refused to produce reports, the Judge would not compel him io do so, but that was in civil proceedings.
Mr. Maitland—I am instructed by the Commissioner of Police not to produce the reports, it being quite clear that departmental communications must be privileged. The third report was made by Gabbutt at the request of the Commissioner, and on the understanding that it would not be used in any manner.
His Worship—It is then a private and confidential report?
Mr. Maitland—Yes. He was told that if he liked to make a report it would not be used in any way against him, His Worship decided to exclude this report, but admitted the first two.
Mr. Reader Harris then intimate ed that he would like this private and confidential report te go in. Det.-Sub-Inspector Gabbutt had na
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.