To the Editor of the "Norta-Cama Dainty News."
Sir,—I venture to suggest that, in the interests of the ratepayers, the results of the Municipal Electricity Department require very careful investigation. We are asked to admire the contribution of Tls. 690,000 to the General Funds. Very admirable too! But how is it made? Which of the departments' various outlets is most profitable? Apparently it is not considered desirable to show this at all exactly, and while the revenues from street lighting, heating and traction are separately stated, the revenues from private lighting and power are lumped together inthe total of Tis. a64, 315.33. Even in these days of thinking in millions, such a total is, I submit, worthy of division..
I am probably only one of many ratepayers who would rather be told of the comparative revenue from power and private lighting, than of the comparative load factors of Shanghai and Manchester. Being denied this information I have tried to work it out for myself and the result of my investigation is rather startling. For the sake of clarity I have worked from the increase of units sold in 1922 as compared with 1921, as shown on Page 4-C. There are fewer figures involved than in working from the grand total consumption.
On Page 4-C it is shown that the increase in private lighting was 2,334,454 units and the increase in power was 43,650,852. From the accounts we find that the increase of revenue from private lighting and power together (Page 13-C) was Tls. 959,680.
Now, if the 2,334,454 additional: units sold for private lighting, were sold at 13 can-darkens per unit, they account for Tls. 303,479, leaving Tls. 656,- 201 as the revenue from the 43,- 560,852 additional units sold for power, or at the rate of 1.50 candareens per unit. Taking the whole additional revenue from lighting and power and dividing it by the whole increase of units sold for these two purposes, we have an income of 2.093 candareens per unit.
On Page 14-C we are given a table showing clearly a steady annual reduction in the cost rer unit sold, but from this we ind that the cost last year, although the lowest on record, was 2.14 candareens.
It would thus appear that the proportion of last year's increase which was sold at cheap rates for power, was so great as to swamp) the proportion sold for {private lighting at a profitable rate, andj i to bring about an actual loss on; this additional business.
I venture to assert, Sir, that the; Electricity Committee needs to] look more closely into the business side of their department, ior a few more years of such increases will resulti in the Return on Capital; Outlay, which has just been reduc-j International Settlements can
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.