The Archive · 1923

The Case of the Late

MR. SMEATON

To. the Editor of the "Norra-Cuina Dairy News."

Sin,—ln my capacity of legal: adviser of the Eyench Municipal Council cannot let pass without) protest the letters published by various correspondents on, the Smeaton's case. it is an injurious misrepresentation of the feelings of the French Municipal Council's members, to saggest that they are pitiless with) the unfortunate widow and chil? dren of the late and much regret+ ted Mr. Smeaton.

In fact, from the very beginning, the Council was prepared to give them help and assistance. But the representatives of Mrs. Smeaton having at once raised the question of legal responsibility in the accident, the Council had nothing to do but to defend to the action.

Then the matter went on the judicial ground and became consequently subject to the usual delays of a lawsuit.

That is the only reason why the plaintiffs have not yet received the indemnity they claimed for. As to the figure of the same, I must point out that the French Consulan Court in Shanghai reduced the plaintiffs demand from Tls. 20,000 to Ts, 14,600, on the ground that Mr. Smeaton was himself responsible of his sad accident, by run-ping quite imprudently to catch the tram, Thercfure it ig unjust and unfair to accuse the members of the French Municipal Council to be heartless and to make the baseless supposition that they intend to apply to the Cour de Cassation int Paris, in order to delay the matter. As soon og the decision of the Court of Appeal in Saigon will be officially confirmed, I am sure that the indemnity awarded to Mrs. Smeaton and her children will be paid up, without necessity of any public meeting of any kind.

But your correspondents would have been, well advised in realizing that a Municipal Council is an administrative personality, the duty of which is to defend as much as possible the interests of the municipal budget, i.e, the inter+ ests of the ratepayers themselves.

With regard, to the suggestion that Mr. Wilden should not have, as Chairman of the French Municipal Council, authorized the latter to appeal against the judgment he had rendered as President of the French Consular Gourt, it shows a very strange conception of the duties our Consul-General has to perform. When he handed over to Mr, do la Prade the Presidency of the Municipal Council, he did do so evidently to let the chairman and the elected members deliberate freely and not at his own command. Besides it would be a virs' if w Judge could take advantage of his authority as Conswi-General, in interfering with the normal course of legal proceed ings.

The respect for justice is laid upon everybody—the Judge included—and especially upon those who having applied to the courts of have beforehand accepted their unavoidable formalities.

Now then Mr. Smeaton's case is to be settled shortly and Li think there are many other topics, which shall better deserve the attention and interest of your readers.

Thanking you in anticipation for your courtesy.

I am, etc., A. pu Pac po Marsouttes.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account