Plaintiffs' representatives, the Central Lid., Shanghai, discovered Hab Kee Factory, Swatow, used @ trade mark which was com: posed of a chian and an anchor and which the plaintiffs considered tobe fan infringement or imitation of their registered trade marks. Consequently, the plaintiffs on July 1, of the 19th Year (1930) filed "a protest with the Bureau of Trade Marks, requesting that the trade mark of the Hah Kee Factory be cancelled. The Trade Marks Bureau, in ruling on the proest, held that the Trade Mark No. 12578 of the Hah Kee Factory be cancelled. The Hah Kee Factory appealed againat, or applied for a reconsideration of the said decision, and Jsuch appeal. delivered another decision firming the first decision Upon further appeal to the Minisiry of Industry by the Hah Kee Factory, the former dismissed the appeal, The Hah Kee Factory again appealed to the Exective Yuan, and, as a result of such appeal, the Executive Yuan rendered a decision reversing the decision of the Ministry of Industry and holding that the trade mark No. 12576 of the Hah Kee Factory be allowed to remain on the register kept for the registration of trade marks. 'The plaintiffs, being dissatisfied with the decision of the Executive Yuan, filed a complaint with this Court and lodged a subsidiary claim for damages. 'The allegations as set forth in the plaintiffs' petition are briefly as fol-
The "Mao Mah" trade mark wed by the Hah Kee Factory is a com: dinatfon of a chain and an anchor which are not only identical with but igo a reproduction of the plainti' "Chain" and "Anchor" trade marks. The Bureau of Trade Marks, in both of its decisions, and the Ministry of Industry upon its last decision, held that the trade mark used by the Hah Kee Factory was an infringement of the plaintiff "Chain" and "Anchor" trade marks and ruled that the "Mao /Mah" trade mark should be expunged, but the Executive Yuan, upon appeal by the Hah Kee Factory, reversed all former decisions, on the grounds \hat the plaintifis had in the actual use fof their trade marks made such changes as consiitite deviations from their registered trade marks and that the exclusive right to the use of such trade marks became lost; also that the "Mao Mah" trade mark No, 12576 was not identical with the trade marks Which were being actually. used by the plaintiffs; and therefore held that. the Hah Kee Factory's, "Mao Mah"
(Continued on page 116.)
(Continued on page 116.)
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.