The Archive · 1935

Combination of Marks

The plaintiffs allged that they have: used their trade marks in exactly the same way as they were originally reg-Istered and have made no changes whatsoever thereon and that this fact can be proved by their books as well as by the testimony of their dealers; that the chain used by the Hah Kee Factory Is identical with the chain used by J. & P. Coats, Ltd, and that the anchor used by the said factory Is Identical with the anchor used by Clark & Ca, Lid, that the trade ematk used by the said factory clearly a combination of the chain and anchor used by, the plaintits, 'The plaintiffs are of opinion that the decision given by the Executive Yuan to hold that the trade mark used by the Hah Kee Factory was not identical with either the plaintifis' "Chain" or "Anchor" trade marks, and that the use of the trade mark by the Hab Kee Factory is not subject to the exclusive rights of the plaintiff, is contrary to law, and they request that the said decision be reversed and that damages be allowed, The reply, by the defendant briefly "as follows:—The registered trade marks of the plalntif chain and an anchor which form the designs of their trade marks. The trade mark of the Hah Kee factory ig composed of a chain and sa Saag wa ade matt similar, at al], with either the plain-"Chain or "Anchor" marks, a3 the Hah Kee Facto "Anchor" trade mark Is a combina-! tion of two main features—a chain and an anchor. Further, also, that the trade marks actually used by the plaintifis were varied from their Tegistered "Chain" and "Anchor" trade marks. which are also not Identic il with the Hah Kee Factory's! "Mao Mah" trade mark; that the plaintiffs, by adopting a varied trade mark, have lost their exclusive rights and that the decision uphold-Ing the "Mao Mah" trade mark Is 19 order.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account