The Archive · 1935

Defendants' Answer

"Defendants' answer is for brevity' sake that the colour applied cannot be said not to be material of the constitution of " trademark because; Art, 1 section 2 of the Trademark Law provides that a trademark, shall also be designated with the colour applied and that the labs! practically used cannot be said to have no relation with the constitution of the whole trademark although here is mo restriction of the size and therefore the difference of the jour and the difference of the size SuMcient "to come to a conclu sion that the whole trademarks are dissimilar and that they are not] wrong in cancelling the decision in appeal and granting registration the Mountain and Lion trademark on basis of the above conclusion. usage of various countries, Similar Designs "The registered trademark No. 11736 of the plaintiffs in the present (Lion and Sun) ts a running lion, semi-circled sun, and rays emitted from. the sun' with flower grass and tree outside and the ap-Proved trade mark No, $316 of Sung Ming Gas Mantle Factory (Mountain and Lion) is a crouching ion, semi+ circled sun and rays emitted from the sun with a mountain and tree outside, Although the arrangement is ttle different the principal features are both the lion, sun and sun rays. From the separate observation of the present packings of the there Is really the danger of con: founding by the buyer, Naturally it cannot but be said as similar" as ent. Itshould be known that if the trademark is registered without designating Its colour only the registerer cannot claim the right of use of th: colour which he applies towards another party. How can. the I sun and sun-rays be disregarded and the above two trademarks concluded be not similar only from the difference in colour?

"As regards the statement that the size of the 2 labels is different and the trademarks practically used by the plainti! was bigger" than the label' originally submitted by one third which is deemed to have rel Yon with the constitution of the whole trade mark, the trademark owner's liberly to use the reduced or one larged Wrademark and it is. not another different. trademark if the form is not changed, Therefore it is impossible to adjudge whether is similar or not on basis of the size of the trade mark, The decision the once of appeal is of the opinion that the general buyer only discerns the lion and sun and cannot dis" Linguish the rest carefully. 'The siml= larity so-called in 'Trademark Low just refers to this act. This opinion is not yet wrong. The decision in e-appeal cancelled the decision and still granted' the registration of the Mountain, & Lion Trademark whicn con really hardly be said to be just and proper. That the Plaintitts made attack on this point in their action of course has to be admitted os Justified.

"On the above grounds we come the conclusion that the plaint faction is well founded and decide as decree In accordance with Art, 21 the Law relating to Administrative Action, strangely askew, leaning forward in to resume his Interrupted conversation with Jennifer, to tell her, with the muttered again; alla schoolboy's eagerness to' share can you Keep a secret?" precious secret with his best friend, of his engagement to Cynthia Palfrey, the exquisite original of a elation that Sir Roger Coverdals "Lady with 'a Fan," the portrait was undoubtedly drunk (the vintage which had brought' him a riehlyport for the banquet scene had Geserved Associateship and which Been another touch of realism, a Jennifer herself had bought for the touch which, gs Lady Foggerty had Werepath collection only a month said so wittily, would do a lot to ago. make the whole world swim during Mrs. Herepath-Fox's admission to the pageant) and that drunk or not, the Order of St Cecilia shortly he was truthfully informing her after the brilliant success of the that his wife bad been certified sane Herepath Pageant of Church His-after twenty years, would be ar ory was a topic of conversation in understatement amounting to a par-the County for many days beyond mentary reply. the traditional nine.

'Lady Coverdale had been presumed dead for as long as Jennifer yore women will go to any lengths as Adela' Rummage remarked could remember, and Jennifer's for the sake of publicity. memory, if infinitely more charity able, was no less keen 'Adela Rummage's, which is saying a good Twe Government of Manchoukuo deal. has approved of the town planning 'With a crash the chapel door was tung open, and' Jennifer's reeling budget compiled by the Municipality of Greater Harbin, which calls. for senses were assaulted yet again by the clatter of four armoured figures. expenditure of 27 million dollars their drawn swords gleaming wicked-during a period of three years.

in the sombre light as they pavaneed upon the chancel Tur population of Amoy is 181,002, Nigel turned, and acting with according to the latest statistics superb dignity, demanded the reason available, This total_ includes 10,364 for their sacrilege in a voice foreigners and 9,048 Formosans, Kulwhich Jennifer could barely recog snug and "Heshan are not cluded nisse. Tt seemed so far away centuries "away.

'With a great effort Jennifer steel 'Tre Kiao-tsi_ Railway Unking ed herself' to watch the acting. Ar Tsingtao and Tainan made " profit angry shout from the four knights more than $4,000,000 during' 1034 four" blades thrust realistically recording 10 the report made public through Nigel's satin robes, and Mrs.

'Tsinan. The total income of the Herepath-Fox knew no more. oilway for passenger and freight rafe was 16,003,007 which repre It' was not until the following: vents an increase of more than morning that Nigel March was able 31,000,000 over 1033.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account