"Under these circumstances I am not certain if I have a right to appeal, but T should like to look into the matter," said Mr, J. T. Hammond when their Honours Judge Sir Skinner Turner and Judge Grain, at H.M. Supreme Court on Saturday, dismissed a motion that the award of the arbitrators in the cases of T. V. Soong v. Hammond, and Hammond v. Wellmann (Nos. 1 and 2) be set aside. '"'Very well," remarked the Chief Judge to defendant, "if you want to take this matter to London, you can put ina formal motion for appeal."
The plaintiff T. V. Soong asked Tls. 1,460, damages assessed by Mr. R. B. Moorhead and Mr. P. Tilley (referees) and costs in respect of a dispute over a lease and_ repairs. The case terminated so. far as the Court was concerned on January 6, 1922, when the Full Court allowed Mr. Hammond's appeal, revising the original judgment, and thereafter referees were appointed. The two actions between Hammond and Wellmann were tried at the same time.
Mr. A. Y. Ting appeared for the plaintiff Tsoong, Mr. P. W. Goldring for Wellmann and Mr. Ham-mon in person.
In the course of a long address to their Lordships, Mr. Hammond moved that he was not heard, and ought to have been, by the arbitrators, before they gave their finding, and that they received more than they were entitled when they fixed their remuneration. As a real estate man, Mr. Hammond declared that the referees' finding was the was the most unusual thing he had ever heard of. It was full of things he did not understand. Had the document been in Chinese he could not have grasped it any better.
Giving the decision of the Full Court, the Chief Judge said that it had put the matter in the hands of practical men, two well-known architects. Defendant's main contention was that he was entitled to be heard by the arbitrators, and that he had not been allowed to call any fresh evidence before them. There was no need for the hearing of any fresh evidence by the arbittators. They were expressly granted the discretion as to whether they should hear the parties, or whether they should take no further evidence. They exercised their discretion, deciding not to hear the parties. As regards the figure awarded, they had dealt with the matter as practical men themselves. Judgment would be in the terms of} the award, less Tls. 60 and $80 already paid.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.