July 21.
Tue statement. made by Mr. Shinwell m.p. in the House of Commons on Wednesday with reference to British shipping in Chinese waters must not be allowed to pass without notice. He suggested that there were very strong comments all along the China Coast with regard to the section of the Merchant Shipping Act relating to the complement of officers to be carried aboard ships, this, let it be noted, in connexion with a disaster off the Malayan coast resulting in the sinking of the steamer Rance after a collision with the steamer Boribat. The Malayan coast is sufficiently far away from China to make the reference at first sight none too easy to grasp, and it must be admitted that the summary of Mr. Shinwell's remarks telegraphed to us suggests that he has made a misleading statement, one even prejudicial to shipping companies which operate in these waters and which. have for so long maintained the best traditions of the mercantile marine. In so much his remarks have been unfortunate, the more so as he undoubtedly had an excellent case to lay before Parliament. Mr. Shinwell was, of course, referring to the class of steamers employed in the coasting trade, and to appreciate his point we must bear in mind that the Merchant Shipping Act lays down that in addition to the master such vessels must carry one other certificated deck officer. The leading " British companies engaged in this trade do not content themselves with abiding solely by the provisions of this clause, but for the safety of their ships, their cargoes and the passengers they carry; em: ploy not only a master but two certificated deck officers as well, and in some cases three. Experience as well as careful inquiry has shown that this is a full provision for the requirements of the case, and there can be no hint of complaint on the score of what these companies The fact that such is the practice of these- long-established firms may possibly be construed-into an impeachment of the present jutility of the Merchant Shipping Act, and in certain circles it is. When the Act was passed there was nothing like the amount of shipping in these waters—we are solely concerned with ithem—that is found to-day, and while it was doubtless. sufficiently _comprehensive when enacted, it is strongly contended by those intimate with present conditions that it is no longer so. This vie¥* was recently brought to the notice of politicians at Home by the China Coast Officers' Guild, but whether it is on this letter that Mr. Shinwell has based his remarks or"upon some other information, we are unable to state. The position, brought out strongly in the case of the Rance-Boribat disaster—one involving considerable loss of life—is that in periods of stress, the provision of one officer in addition to the captain is inadequate, especially in view of the congestion of sea routes, and that an amendment is called for.
Now, to return to Mr. Shin-well's statement, there are a certain -number of British steamers trading in these waters which' have only one deck officer in addition to-the captain, but we believe that there are. even more of other nationalities. A considerable number of Chinese companies, for instance, now run steamers, and they are subject to no Board of Trade laws. The only influence that can be brought to bear upon them to come into line with the practice of other steamers is that of the harbour and like authorities, and it is to the credit of the latter that so much has been achieved in the direction of the appointment of certificated officers. This and similar circumstances may have been responsible for a certain amount of confusion in a consideration of the facts at Home, and as likely as not has been responsible for the misleading character of Mr. Shinwell's statement.
In view, however, of the danger to navigation which may result when only the bare requirements of the Merchant Shipping Act as regards officers are complied with, the subject was an eminently proper one to ventilate in Parliament. The facts in the Malayan disaster were that the Boribat carried only a master and one other officer, and at the time of the collision with the Rance the master was asleep on the bridge. But for three days and nights he had been on duty, and as the court pointed out there were limits to human endurance. That was a perfect illustration of the case which the Coast Officers' Guild wished to bring to notice. There is no question of any shortage of experienced officers, for unemployment in the-mercantile marine _is_ unfortunately too common. What the Labour Party really wants, in common with others, is an amendment of the Act with the object of bringing all steamers into line with the Practice adopted by so many companies. The moment, however, any Government, measure of the kind might be introduced we should hear an -outery, and it would be pointed out that a measure such as that would drive many vessels to the shelter of other flags where less stringent regulations are in force. This is probably the bugbear facing any attempt legislation, and it may be doubted whether the Government today feels itself strong enough to face the situation. Even so, there seems every reason why the reform should be urged, on the ground that not to one ship only is there possibility of danger, but to all shipping.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.