The Archive · 1935

Pots and Kettles

April 24.

Japanese and British statesmen have, from time to time, had the privilege of receiving letters from Dr. Robert Hornabrook on the subject of international affairs. After a distinguished career in preventive medicine and, during the Great War, in the Royal Army Service Corps, Dr. Hornabrook has managed, in the cause of a busy general practice in Melbourne, to lapply his experience and epistolary zeal to the examination of world problems. To the "Japan Adver-{tiser" he has disclosed this amiable hobby and, what is more, has confided the text of a letter lately addressed to an unknown British statesman who is given the label influential" with the sub-title, "connected with the League of Nations". Dr. Hornabrook deals with the Manchurian issue. The "influential" statesman is invited to observe that Great Britain "missed a golden opportunity" and the Lytton Commission "made a mess of things" over Manchuria, The letter proceeds:

"Coercion or velled threats of! coercion are not going to help the situation, and the man or Government that thinks it is a fool.

"We are not such perfect angels ourselves, and when it comes to dirty work some of us who took active part in the South African War and were in that country prior to that war are not too protd either of ourselves or of the actions of the British Government which led up to that war, "When we start to crucify Japan for her work, let us take the cloak of self-righteousness off our own shoulders. It is a case of the pot calling the kettle black.

"The trouble with our so-called leaders at Home in the old Mother country is that we never see you fellows who land the old Empire in a mess going through hell and taking your place in the front line trench when trouble does arise of the result of your folly." would be interesting to know whether Dr. Hornabrook had found time, in the midst of his indefatigable correspondence, to read the Lytton Report. He would be surprised at the small support which that document gave to any idea of coercing Japan or of allowing pots to call kettles black. Looking back at the events following the /Mukden episode of September 1931, it certainly would not appear {to observers outside Melbourne that there had been much talk of coercion, except in so far as the idea may have arisen from some of the more flamboyant gestures of the Japanese General' Staff or from those periodical, but always illuminating, indiscretions attributed to a "spokesman" in Tokyo.

Dr. Hornabrook seems imperfect-equipped for the instruction of "influential" statesmen and for his self-imposed task of contributing to Anglo-Japanese "understanding". He is credited with the view that the termination of the Anglo-Ji anese Alliance was "a great folly". That is a familiar argument, but even if it be accepted it does not carry Dr. Hornabrook or anyone else very much further for the simple reason that its revival is not practical measure of present-day politics. Great Britain, as a Member of the League, has definite bilities which are incompatible with any such diplomatic machinery. That does not preclude perseverance in the consolidation Anglo-Japanese friendship to which, however, Dr. Horabrook's ustion is not calculated to make aay solid contribution. Japan, of course, must be allowed to take the view that an el, if discredited, Imerialistic technique was better suited to her needs than the rew dispensation established under the aegis of the League. She based her withdrawal presumably on that perfectly legitimate contention. She would hardly maintain that the Lytton Commission, appointed at her request within the fold of the League, could report on such premises, -or that Great Britain Manchuria found full endorsement therein, He feels that the League has lacked "commonsense and tact". Without attempting to fill all the gaps in Dr. Hornabrook's knowledge of Geneva, it may be enough to restate the obvious fact that the League is not a superman's trade union but merely an association of quite human nations endeavouring to prevent that very "hell" of which Dr. Hornabrook so feelingly writes. The League 1s just what those members make it, And it is significant that, despite her withdrawal, Japan is freely ce-operating with the League in important humanitarian activities, notably disarmament, misses the mark. Japan, for reasons which appear to her to be sound, is inclined to retread once more the path of power-diplomacy which other nations within the League are endeavouring to avoid, in the belief that the collective system affords the best promise of peaceful solution of world diftculties. There is no condemnation of Japan but rather regret that the faith which she so conspicuously showed as an original signatory of the Covenant, has faltered. "Her self-chosen spiritual isolation is not necessarily final. She is constantly showing signs of a statesmanlike desire to keep well abreast of the beneficent movements [this new world creed. Less than [justice is done to her by 3 alting her hesitancies to the status defiant dogmas or by manufactur ing grievances for her out of the situation which her doubts have produced, Nor is this view inconsistent with the belief that the League, with the rest of the world, still' in the process of learning from its mistakes—let Dr. Hornabrook be made a present of that admission. 'The apparent rigidity the collective system has sensibly decreased. Japan may even clair that her own difficulties' have helped to set that process at work, There is less disposition to treat that system as a goal in itself and 'a greater effort to adapt it to the re-eminent service of peace. This /may—it should—develop means for surer reconciliation of Japan's needs with the machinery for International ce-operation, Tu so far, therefore, as Dr, Hornabrook in Melbourne intends to pursue his valuable study of public affairs, it may be appropriate for him to consider the advantage of looking forward rather than wasting his time and "influential" statesmen's patience in ingenuous but essentially defective retrospects. It is not the slightest good inviting pots to call kettles black. The practical man will seek to make both give the culinary service desired, according to their different idiosynerasies, under the motive power of common inspiration—the advancement of civilization's progress,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account