The Archive · 1934

Logical Processes Some Quotations

To the Editor of the "NontH-Cuina Dany News"

Sin,—In the issue of your journal under date of December 20, U-K.y one of your able correspondents, has been good enough to rectify ' the fallacy of my logical processes, ad-Vising me to set a cart of "Chinese Doycott" before the horse of "Japanese. aggression" in conformity with his didactic ukase, When an Illustrious gentleman like Lord Lytton brings to our view a formid dobie array of "statistical data," there must be a considerable me wre of truth which will serve to reinforce U.K.'s specious argu: ments, Be it\ remembered, however, that Yoshitaka is not te be a blind follower of current opinion." His original position and pious desire is to be A stern critic. As a matter of fact, he is almost inimical to any the-on advanced by ultra-nationalist Feactionaries, Neither is he friend-only visionary communists or: to doctrinaires' cosmopolitanism, He is only athirst for true knowledge of men and events, Then, even granting all that U.K.

to be true, the question to be still remains " unanswered; the Sino-Japanese troubles?"

Apparently, U-K. has ingeniously arrayed some facts in the order of certain causation. So, far, he has fuceeeded in his task, but he has to still further. Otherwise how fin he answer some of the follow-diatribes:

china' to and only, ings a plomacy. are exploiting. the supPesslmlicity: of the "forelgnerny whom one ives. no ered. (or THK gid pissing one' weale the Pom time immemorial China, her" own hatiies, has. folfewed the oth "unable and unwilling to. Aight Aina polley of playing the orcin? against the nearer" person livin of discipline and fhotity,'apon which th relentless pursuance of that advan-age. For, who knows, if "Yoshita-Kop" ight hot yet be! von aver that Liberalism he so earnestly protested through four columns?

"The political pendulum has swung to the other direction. The only thing we can do at, present is to wait" patiently until it swing ack to a reasonable position." Reminiseent of the Shidehara era, "Yoshitaka" would thus advise us.

For more than two years, with words as much as deeds, the World Watched patiently the, pendulum rwing—irrevoeal one direefon, Ghina neither could nor would offer but a half-hearted resistance—resistance such may, be called. The only impatience has been in the haste with which Japan plunges Divine Destiny" of ria ET incident" to the Jehol, to this even tty pan a continent datamt ret tlls'ot shanghai. very exten soe the Japanese actirtles snd Hat Shion has been, prayed for by See be the last to be the ex tremity to which the pendulum would swing. Hadn't she and the Worl Been'given such an assurance ofthe "patience of the World Man? be "nothing wanting Tar, mon thavatened, an Chine, Tee rear elites ie has avoid: Tyth mesinlona which could be fnbisset ough as to queen the deerreiy of Japan's adi-righteous propriety sot fall mentha were. Te: Guire for the Lytton Commission to gees fat (Ching, after completing arutenty. ite ineraey in Americ rae oman, wale Chapel, waste Feed hes Another atx months sed, part of which had first to upibyed. forthe ata of the conditions in' Chaa", up

wee ttnmiRea, "get another.

Fantse for the. Report 8 sietns was devoted mule aces" Only Jape Traptacsbihiy even in the matter faptasrmmuliy was able to force Sapei's'answer to_all that, pat-ions of the League and the Public sic of fo mention the Impoe

Compl after the other, by been one fait acsaeratormatity of sIniependence Tpecogniion:® had to be rose raReGRe" withdrawal "fromthe true could of unit the lose of without which th arettet horde' of young, hood Furthermore, I wonder if U.K. is able to answer the following in-

All along, China has patiently reseaged Tron Invoking Article XVI Sine! rape' Covenant to. compel the members to the "immediate seeet al tae or financial re: agence oft Wt Sapan for her resort to war," declared or unde-del: "our Government would "AMI the world In China i, mors {zaly th" anywhere, a ataey bd al even avait patiently the llnare One pleasure of the International Au-

China thorities: and only time was it, when "nieh hay been ayetematieally misrule and governed neouraged to Indulge in manifesto Seaune of offence. to. the Hours"

passant only to remind U: K. of the Above quotations apy given, terious plight besetting China, not in anyway to blacken deliberately, the fair name of China.* It is Nincerely hoped that U.K. will think more deeply about his own country. In the meantime, T will endeavour to appreciate the last Words of Miss Edith Cavell, "Patriotism is not enough"!

Shanghai, Dee, 28.

have not verified the quotations but they are, I think, from Mr. Rodney Gilbert's books.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account