The Archive · 1936

DELIGHTFUL ANTHOLOGY Tue Muste Lovers Muscruiawy Selected and Ealted by Erle Dom. Gollanes, London, 1/6.

This ts a delightful anthology of quotations—grave, witty, sentimental, pltetul, wise, stupid, pedantls, super ficlal—on every aspect of the muslcal art, compiled from biographies, essays, elters, novels, memcig, in fact from every possible literary Jrource from the Bible to James Joyce's "Ulysses". It is an extraordinarily catholic selection and is] well calculated to afford both In+ struction and amusement to. music lovers. Perhaps the latter emotion will predominate. Whether by the chance of selection or as reflecting. the temperament of the comaller, a large number of the quotations will fraise a smile at the prejudice or the Tenorance of the writer, or at a Jerticlsm of or panegyric upon con~ temporary music which the passage years has rendered _nugatory, Thus, in 1841 the "Musical World wrote of Liszt as "the Aurora Borealls of musical effulgence": a, con temporary of Bach stigmatized his works as made "unnatural by bombast and confusion"; Edward Bulwer Lytton wrote, "Many. volees of men and women joined in deeper bass with the shrill tenor of the choral furehins"; and Bolleau, in a letter t9 Racine, was convinced that "A. good opera will never be written. Music Joes not know how to narrate." Ac~ fording to the "Morning Chronicle" of August 16, 18% after performing with the ill ant execution a. sonata on forte in the presence of Dr. ohtaum, took the liberty of asking wns fong of music. "Nor udam," replied the Doctor, "but of nolsee 1 think musie the least dls=

The captions to the quotations are well-chosen, For instance, the Tine from Coleridge's "Ancient. Mariner":

The Wodding-Guest here beat his For he heard the loud bassoon. fare headed "Overdoing Criticism: Altogether a book for the music-lover's table—w.s.0,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account