In the British Supreme Court, on Thursday, Dr. G. G. Irons, dental surgeon, sued R. T. Ryton, of 362 Avenue Joffre, for $160 for professional services rendered to defendant's wife. Mr. C. F. Frank. lin appeared for the plaintiff.
Plaintiff gave evidence that defendant's wife consulted him with regard to the reconstruction of an old bridge for her teeth, which he put right and for which he told her his charges would be between $60 and $70, but whilst attending to that he found that other teeth needed treatment and he also did what was necessary to them. He sent in a bill for $160, which the defendant protested wts an exorbitant amount and more than had been agreed upon. 'They were his usual charges and wittness suggested that the defendant should refer the bill to' any other foreign dentist in Shanghai for arbitration. After some correspondence, witness offered to settle the bill for $100, but this offer was refused. Defendant sent him a cheque for $70, refusing to pay more and he had since refused to take this cheque back.
"'In one letter," said plaintiff, "Mrs, Ryton was very insulting to me. 1 shall not bring that up just now, but may do so at some future date.""
Weness read several letters which passed between the defendant or Mu. Kyton and himself, in one of which, Mrs. Ryton referring to the alleged agreement on an inclusive charge of $70, wrote, "My mind is absolutely clear, 1 do not indulge' in cigar revies, drinks or late nights." Witness remarked, "That is the statement 1 take exception to."
Defendant stated that, after Dis wife had received attention from the plaintiff, she continued in pain and had to go to another The Judge—What is his name?
Vetendant—He does not want 1t mentioned in court.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.