The Archive · 1923

Court for China

Judgement in an action at the instance of la Pavlovna Kamoff against the International Banking Corporation has been delivered in the United States Court for China by his Heaour Judge Lobingier. Mr. I. A. Landesman appeared for the plaintiff and Messrs. Shoop Chalaire for the defendant, The grounds of his Honour's judgment were that an*attorney's lien-upon "money in the hands of the adverse party" attaches only "from the time of giving notice of the lien to that party." A mere notice to the effect that the attorney is receiving a certain percentage fails to meet such requirement. Written notice of a claim of lien is not expressly required, but is always much safer and more satisfactory.

Judge Lobingier's decision was as follows On August 6, 1923, an applica~ tion was filed by plaintiff "to discontinue the proceeding herein," on the ground that she had received "full satisfaction from the defendant with reference to the above claim." This application is opposed by her attorney of record on the ground that the set~ tlement was negotiated without his knowledge and that he has not been paid a fee of 10 per cent. of the amount recovered, which plaintiff admits having promised him. The attorney resists the application.to dismiss as a method of enforcing an attorney's lien, which he claims by virtue of the following provision "An attorney has a lien for his compensation, whether specially agreed upon or implied, as provided in this section.... (3) Money in the hands of the adverse party in an action or proceedings in which the attorney was employed from the time of giving notice of the lien to that party.""

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account