swaTow To the Editor of the Sin.—I was greatly interested the letter from Swatow and in the comments upon it, under the head~ of "Consular Jurisdiction," which appeared in your issue of Monday The facts, as presented, appear to be regarded as a reflection, some measure, upon the British Consul in Swatow. Ho was called in to secure the liberty of a Brit ish subject who had been wrongfully arrested. Instead of drawing the attention of the Superintendent of Police to the international agrecments regarding extraterrito hho advised the British subject to pay $50 of $100 to end the matter.
The immediate assumption is that the Consul is a very weak-kneed oficial. I have heard several casual case.
'Swatow soams to have made.a big of a fool of himself." You, Sir, are apparently inclined to endorse' this view. You deal with the subject im more dignified language, but your inquiry and, possibly, for action, I presume you mean departments action against the Consul.
'This superficial judgment is te my mind grossly unjust. "1 do n Know Mr. Major, and I hold Grief for British' Consuls or for British officials of any grade, but it offends my British sense of fair play to find, when things go wrong, that individuals are saddled responsibility which others shoul@ shoulder.
There is another aspect of this Swatow affair which I would pre sent for your attention. The easy conclusion of British subjects out here is, of course, that the Consul should have buckled on his little oficial sword and demanded the release of this British subject. Very well. The demand is refused. What then? The Consul cables to Peking and the reply is that he must settle the matter without creating any unpleasant incident. This has hag pened before and doubtless will happen again, Where is our pres tige then? Whose fault is it that we are placed in such an unfortunate position? Surely not the Consul's.
Unless the Consul can rely upon the support of his Government ha is in no better position to enforce a demand than you or I, Sir, 'That essential point seems to' be entirely overlooked in Why bl which has developed when the fault Vies with the British people and, through them, their elected representatives—the British Goverms ment?
'Since that Government has adopt~ ed a policy' of expediency, instead of principle, in China these incl dents are bound to arise and I sug= gest that it is entirely wrong to blame individual officials for them, If T had been British Consul Swatow in the circumstances outlined I should have refused to go to the Chinese Police Station at al T should have sent a chit with th office boy, advising the unfortunate British subject to pay the blackmail. Then I should have forwarded full details of my action to Poking and waited hopefully for lotter of appreciation of my tack and, in due course, for the C.ML.G, Tam, ete,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.