The Archive · 1929

American Debt Ratification

July 24.

The ratification of the war debt agreement with the United States was a long and painful process. The Chamber of Deputies devoted fifty hours to the debate, which wound up, at 2 am.

atmosphere of feverish excitement. The resolution authousing the President of the Republic to sign the ratification was adopted by majority of only eight in the absence of Mr. Poincare, who had broken down under the strain and was obliged to remain in bed.

The Chamber was rather like a man who finds himself: obliged to Rose a tooth which he thinks might have been saved if his dentist had treated it differently. The same arguments were repeated over and over again in different forms, although the only real question. was whether France was to honour her signature. All the private members who spoke were. labouring under a bitter sense of injustice, They could not understand why the United States, after voluntarily joining in the war, should treat their former allies on business Jines when accounts came settled, Such an attitude seemed to them not merely illogical but, heartless. Repeated attempts. were made to surround the ratification with reservations so. that, if Germany failed to pay France, France should not have to pay the United States, and the Government had to point out over and over again that it was a question of a plain "Yes"

After the principal vote, the ratification of the agreement with the other creditor ally, Great Brit. in, was agreed to by a show of hands, without a word, Many' French observers think the debate will hasten the formation of the United States of Europe against America. The Americans will probably console themselves with the reflection that those who have the money cannot expect to be loved for themselves. yibute to Britain's Generosity One result of the debate should be to remove some of the misapprehensions existing in Franco as to the attitude of the second largest creditor, Great Britain, M. Herriot, for instance, said i wi mistake to make no' distinction between the American and the Brit-fish claims. Britain was still handicapped' by unemployment and inn critical position, very largely Jdag to the energy and loyalty to her allies which she showed duvit the war. America was in quite different. position. The money she fadvaneed was only one of her war weapons and it was the one she used during the year that elapsed between her declaration of war and the participation of her troops {in operations on the western front.

M, Jacques Stern, the rapporte of the Foreign Affairs Conmittec, remarked that Great Britain not fonly proposed a general cancellation of the inter-Allied debts but, after having lent her allies £2,000,- 000,000, expressed her readiness to accept half that amount in scttlement. This proof of generosity, M. Stern said, would leave its trace throughout the whole of international life and encouraged the hope that some day all. the Jdcbts would be wiped out. He might have added that the road is open to the United States to by cancelling war debts in a few years, when they are able to reduce their internal taxation to something like the pre-war level. Such an act would at once deprive the United-States-of Europe mo\ ment of its anti American character and remove the obstacles to the development of American trade in Europe,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account