The Archive · 1934

SHANGHAI NOTES

ON BRIEFS

'Mr. Marden holds no brief, 'That is fortunate for his advocacy' is more fenthusiastie than convincing. He "charges" this journal first "wi inconsistency and now with unfairness. He also is worried lest the Council, in proceeding to the duty of electing its Chairman, should pay more attention to "hints" revealed in the voting lists than to other more august pronouncements. The leading article which has stirred his righteous wrath appears to hava been too hastily read by him. It drew attention to the obvious fact that Mr, Arnhold's negligent dismissal of public complaints regarding the bus services Was not tactic leally wise in one who was bid di for election to a position for which responsiveness to public opinion might be considered to be a qualification, It took cordial note of Mr. Arnhold's valuable services and admirable qualities as a Member of the Council and as an office-holder jon the Council, It expressly reco-mized that the appointment of a Chairman was in the Council's hands and it gave no advice, but recorded, as Mr. Marden himself notes, a "hint" in the process of examining the figures. Mr. Marden may say that his argument, in eli minating the Japanese vote,' did not! im then he clearly destroys all reason for giving that interesting statistical table to prove. that 'Arahold could be put at. the top of the poll, by the suitable dis: posal of Agures. His citation' of the' precedent in 1982 is no less damaging to the case which "he socks to make, "Finally, let aid, Mr, Marden has only himeett io thank if his anxiety to ounei from the "untate® duces a" plain statement of const an "inconsistent" newspaper pre

federations which are actively work in many minds. This Journ: -al's comment of January" 31 on, the possibilities of the chairmanship seems to be awarded an appreciation which he pared to give to the offending tide of Wednesday last. Si ince 31 the trafic problem sumed Special. im-

Massey" Report has deeply stirred. portance. The "publication of the the community. The transfer of the head offices of the Tramway Com-Pany to Shanghai is reaching completion. The need for the estab li rib of a Transport Board has been gradually forcing its way to the fore. It therefore seems not unreasonable that, the Council should asked account. the trammelled by any direct association with the public transport services. The bus and tram companies cannot view the Rickshaw Report with a spirit of detachment. Nor can they fairly be asked to constitute then selves "the "exponents, "of public opinion on transport, "problems generally. It will not be contend. fed that thie journal has neglected to draw. full attention to, the efforts made by these companies to cope with their difficult problems. Yet it cannot be denied that pub dissatisfaction exists and the Coun: cil's position as arbitrator between the holders of its franchise and community served by that franchise be seriously embarrassed wers for personal of his experience and advice during the course of such discussions as might conceivably arise in future in that regard. fr. Arnhold may well ask to be saved from "his friends. This journal did not invite the controversy which Mr. Mardea has forced upon it, It has repeat tedly expressed its high opinion of Mr. Armhold's services to the Council, but, without adopting the ha-its of the ostrich, it cannot ignore the disabilities which, for no fault of his own, accrue to Mr. Arnhold {from the growing development of acute public anxiety over the trend of traffic problems. hero in the int mediate issue of the rickshaw éificulty and the, possibly, remoter issue of the creation of some central oficial organization to ce-ordinate the transport services in the best interests of the Settlement. Mr.

garden himself is greatly esteemed here for his own remarkable achievements in the handling of transport and it is surprising therefore this aspect of the arguments which Ihave aroused his resentment has not commended itself to him. For some reason or other he has set out to windmills which really did not exist and has, itis to be feared, become entangled in, the generous emotions of an ill-judged champion-i ship.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account