The Archive · 1923

Charge of Murder on High Seas

Indian Coal-trimmer Found

Guilty on Retrial before H. M. Supreme Court After undergoing his second trial, the 25-year-old Indian charged with the murder of a fellow-countryman in the fo'cale of the Macedonia on August 30, was found guilty and sentenced to death by his Honour Judge Sir Skinner Turner at H. M. Supreme Court on Thursday When the accused, Shagaman K. Hoosien, was charged before the Assistant Judge, the jury were unable to agree, and a retrial was ordered.

Occupying a seat on the bench yesterday was the Hon. R. A. Greenshields, Chief Puisne Judge of Quebec, who is visiting Shanghai.

Counsel in the case were: Mr.

H. P. Wilkinson and Myr. C. Mansel Reece, for the Crown; Mr. R. G. McDonald for the defence. The jury were as follow:—Mr. A. TT. Downie, ~My. E. C. James, Mr. N. Dennison, Mr. <A. O. Ake-hurst, Mr. ©. H. Rutherford, Mr. F. T. Renwick, Mr. V. Harding, Mr. T. W. Scarborough, Mr. D. Fleming, Mr. R. I. Hope, Mr. V. H. Borune and Mr. G. L. Campbell.

In the course of his opening statement for the Crown, Mr. Wilkinson said he anticipated that the defence would be that the accused man was under the influence of a drug, and thus not a person of sound memory or discretion. The law on this point had been gone into very fully of late. There was the case of the Director of Public Prosecutions v. Baird, in which judgment on appeal had been given by the Lord Chancellor in 1920. For a number of years past there had been some important decisions. Counsel would not say that the decisions varied, though some carried the doctrine further than others. Drunkenness originally was no excuse for the crime of murder.

Passing to the evidence that wauld be adduced by the prosecution, the Crown Advocate said he regretted that Det.-Sub-Insp. Yorke, who charged the prisoner, was in hospital and could not be moved. In these circumstances counsel would apply to the Court for permission to read the depositions of this witness. It was the duty of the Crown to mention that analysis of the knife disclose ed no human blood reaction, but it should be explained in this connexion that there was a space of time between the alleged stabbing and giving up by prisoner of the knife. Analysis, however, of the clothes Shagaman was wearing proved that the spots thereon were those of human blood.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account