An appeal against an érder_made in HM, Supreme Court on August 7, 1935, allowing the petitioner divorce case (0 take his child out of the jurisdiction of the court, was heard before the Full Court Appeal on Friday. Judge A. G. Mossop, Judge P, Grant Jones, and Judge R. E, Lindsell, Puisne Judge and acting Chief Justice of Hongkong, presided at the hearing. Mr, H. A. Recks appeared for Mr, G, W. Moss, the petitioner in. the divorce ease, and Mr. J, MeNeilt for the respond-ut, and apneliant in these procendings.
Mr. McNeill said that the jurisdletion of a court in England ina divorce case depended upon the domicile of the petitioner, and proceeded to define the meaning of the word "domicile." In this case, they must take it that the place where the petitioner, who was now on leave tu England, intended to vesicle permanently was still in China, "tne position was that the petitioner intended {o reside in China, and intended to leave the child permanently out of the jurisdiction of the court, A law formerly existed Zor-bidding the access of @ gullly wife to any of her children, but this law had since been changed. He submitted that in making the order appealed against, the Assistant Judge put himself in such a position that he would not in the future be able to grant access of the mother to the child.
The Supreme Court could not make an'order for access if both the petitioner and the child were not within the Jurisdiction of the court. The Court was now precluded from ranting access, although a guilty wife was not now compelled to he Kept away from her child for ever 'Mr. 'MeNeill allowed, however, that if the petitioner were in Shanghai the court could: make an order for access, In reply to a question by 'Judge' Mossop as to what harm the Assistant Judge's order had brought upon the appellant, Mr, MeNeill sala that they did not know whether the petitioner would over definitely re~ turn to Shanghai. Tt was wrong for child of tender years to be entirely removed from its mother's custody He submitted that if the Assistant Judge had intended to Insert a pro-Vision for access to the child, should have appeared in the decree. He understood that during the hear: ing of the divorce case there was considerable discussion as to access The amendment asked for now was that the child should be brought back to Shanghai within a reasonable ume, Mr, Reeks said that the amendment asked for wag that the child should be brought back "within @ period of ix months." This might be a physical impossibility, ax the petitioner might already have left England with Out the child. He submitted that the Assistant Judge had not erred in law, os hod been alleged, and that he had full power to take the child out of the Jurisdiction of the court, There had been no request for access the previous proceedings. He submitted that the Assistant' Judge ox-cercised his discretion perfectly rightly. Tt was against public policy for 8 child to be restrained from going back to the British Isles, and. the appellant was asking that' the child should be deprived of the privileges would have received if she had oot been quilly. 'The welfare of the child, involving the welfare of the race,' was the paramount considera tion, Tt would have been a tremendous hardship if the Judge had order~ ed the child to be brought back witha certain number of months, as the father might have lost_his job the meantime, The case was adjourned.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.