The Archive · 1929

The Story of the Chinese Eastern Railway

DE—The Mukden Agreement of 1924: No Propaganda by Either Side: A Failure from the Start By Guonce E. SoxousKy (The last in thie series appeared in the "Herald" of Auguat $1.)

The Peking Agreement of 1924. was inoperative because Manchuria was, in that year, autonomous poli-paragraph with regard to redemption which reads as follows:

The Union of Soviet Socialist Re-tically and did not recogni the publics agrees, upon the signing of this Jurisdiction of the Peking Government even in international rela~ tions. A separate agreement had to be signed with "The Autonomous Government of The Three Eastern Provinces," if the Peking agreement was to be, at all, effectly Attention must here be' called to the fact that Soviet Russia was Agreement, tothe redemp ablies agrees, up:

the ai Ratleay wite Coinese capital, the. actual" and "fa which to be Axed by the two Contract-Ing Parties.

Article VI of the Peking Agreement deals with propaganda. This repeated almost" verbatim in Article I of the Mukden Agreement. itself antagonistic to the then existent Peking Government, for Borodin had alrendy begun to play his singular rule in South China. and although Soviet Russia was busily organizing throughout the world a "Hands off China" movement, the agents of the Third International were preparing to establish in South Ghina avery effective Russian dictatorship.

The Agreements Compared It {is interesting, from this standpoint to compare the Peking and Mukden Agreements of 1924, Articles LI and IV of the "Peking Agreement deal with the special treaty provisions generally referred to as extraterritorial and treaty rights, In the Mukden Agreement, this phase of the problem iv stated most clearly and succinct y in Article I, Item T:

(1), The Governments of the two Contracting Parties declare that the Chinese Enstorn Railway is a purely commercial enterprise, The Governments of the two Contracting Pa th swith the exe fare under the direct control of the Ratiway, all other matters affectin the Fights of the, National and the The Peking and Mukden Agreements were unworkable from the very start. Every clause contained impractical factors, so. that either side desired that the Agree-nts should fail, failure "was inevitable. It must be remembered that under the 1896 Agreement, (China did not in any way, partake the management of the railway. The entire system was Russian; the business of the ling was conducted in the Russian ° language; the particularities of procedure were Russian. Here were two agreements providing for" dual management, but dual management implies equal authority and responsibility. 'That this was from the outset impossibi parently realized by' both Chinese and the Russians.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account