To. the Editor of the "Norru-Cama Dairy News." music of "the giants'? I would point a warning finger at those contemporaries of Haydn, Mozart, Wagner, Schumann and Brahms who attacked their innovations and denounced their music as hideous cacophony doomed to a speedy death.(I can give chapter Sin,—Since my little question and verse). Even your beloved has had the honour of being Beethoven's works were described "dealt with" in a leading article, by the critics of his time as "the I make no apology for replying effusions of a madman." Verb. at some length. sap!
(1) The original statement was (4) The attempt to impede the that no real music has been pro-natural progress of the art he produced since the nineteenth century. fesses to love by ex cathedra The method of your defence of it generalizations calculated to pre-is, astonishing, the line of argujudice the public mind against its mont being, briefly:—Modern latest developments is not very music does mot rank with that of creditable in your leader-writer, the giants, and furthermore will and certainly does music a dis-not stand the test of time; there-service, Careful, reasoned criticism fore it is not real music. of new music is a very welcome (2) Lo, it be assumed for a feature in a modern newspaper moment fiat your preliminary arbitrary denunciation is objec-arbitrary assertions are correct and tionable and quite unconvincing. that such compositions as Elgar's (5) As regards Richard Strauss, First Symphony and his violin a glance at recent English and concerto, The Rite of Spring," continental concert programmes "Madame Butterfly," "Der Rosen-will reveal the fact that, his tone-cavalier," Scriabin's pianoforte poems and songs are part of the works, "The Hymn of Jesus," the ordinary musical fare nowadays. songs of Parry and Quilter, the The Encyclopaedia Britannica Glazounoy and Raval Chamber says of hit Music do not rank with the "St.
Matthew Passion," the Ninth "That his position is assured amongst the immortals is clear if only on account Symphony and'''Die Meistersinger" of his absolute independence of thought and that they will in the and of expression, of his prodigious course of an unspecified time be breadth of artistic view and of his defunct " and. forgotten, does capacity to say his say in the musical that justify you in dogmatically language of his own day,"? denying to them the title of "real And his "Death and Transfiguramusic'? Does the (alleged) evention" was performed in Worcester tual passing of these compositions Cathedral at the Three Choirs from the minds of future genera-Festival las, month. But you label tions dispose of the fact that to him the "Great Despot of Din"! the musically-educated public of (6) I gather from your last today they are most certainly paragraph that what you consider "real music" the poverty of modern music is Of course not! A work of art due to its Lack of good tunes. Is is none the less a work of art it not possible that the poverty in because it is not in the first rank this matter is in the auditory or because it does not live for ever. powers and experience of the J taka it that no one, save aphearer? No tune in Elgar, Strauss, parently the writer of yor r leader, Glazounov, Debussy? This is terwould) deny_ to a musical comrible! But 1 am reminded of a position which possesses the quali-critic who wrote in 1856 that ties of beauty and artistic purpose "(Wagner is the Arch-enemy of the title of real music.''. That much of the music of Elgar, mush He is incapable of writing a tune?"
Scriabin, Debussy, Hoist and a score of other moderns does pos-(7) In your notice of the Hei-sess those qualities and does-in fitz concert you asked "Why has consequence appeal to the artistic the world produced no violins judgment of the musical public since the seventeenth century would not be questioned by any-and you are at pains to affirm in one who had ever attended a few year leader that, no violin pro-the thousands of concerts where duced since that time is in the such music 1s performed, and even rank of a Strad, a Guarnerius or casually peruses the musical jour-Amati." "The refutation of this nals and the musical columns of assertion is to be found in the newspapers and magazines. I following extract from "The could swamp -your pages with ex-Musical limes" of April last:—tracts and quotations to prove the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.