The Archive · 1923

Mr. Moller and the Hongkong Governmen

To the Editor of the "Nortu-Cuina Datty News."

Sir,—In your issue of September 12, you published (Mr. Fletcher's reply to Mr. C. R Burkill's and my letters of August 14, 1923, and although I have already been permitted to occupy a great deal of space in your columns, I hope you will be so kind as to grant me your usual facilities to reply to Mr. Fletcher's letter.

Myr. Fletcker's letter has been read by both Mr. Burkill and myself with the greatest interest, but as we are evidently at serious variance on certain very important points, I would like to make myself absolutely clear and definite on the subject of our claims and grievances against the Hongkong Government.

I would like, in the first place, to state plainly that there is no misunderstanding whatever on our parts as regards the Shipping Control question.

At the time our vessels were requisitioned under the Hongkong Official Notice dated March 13, 1918, issued, over the signature of Sir Claude' Severn, we were definitely advised by one of the highest legal authorities in Hongkong, that the only possible authority under which our vessels could be taken, was the Order in Council of 1896, and then only for purposes in connection with the aid and defence of the Colony or war requirements.

Tt was on this advice that we immediate'= entered our protest and requested the Hongkong Govment to inform us under what iithority tke requisition was carried out.

Mr. Fletcher now states that the Governor did not requisition the steamers; nor were the ships taken for or in the aid and de fence of the Colony; and further that the said Order in Council never came into the matter of the requisition in any way whatever.

It is on this position that our difference of opinion occurs, and if this is the attitude now taker up by Mr. Fletcher, I consider he is placing his defence under the "Liner Requisition Scheme" in a more undesirable and insecure position, than heretofore.

Mr. Fletcher says that the Hongkong Government acted un-dey the guidance of the Imperial Government.

We do not deny that the Hon'gkong Government acted under the guidance of -the Home Government, but, if such was the case, and they desired to follow instructions, it was up to the Hongkong Government, before they took such serious steps of taking other people's properties and profiteeringg with them... see that they were armed with the fullest legal authority, because it would

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account