The Archive · 1923

A Case for Reprieve

To the Editor of the Norrg-Cuina Darty News."

Sm—Everybody who has a feeling for justice must agree with the leading article "A' case for reprieve' in your paper today. As a specialist in legal psychology, I would call attention to the fact that in this case a thorough psychological examination, don modern science could have decided, with nearly absolute certainty, whether the accused was in an unconscious state of mind; this was omitted and thus it was not possible for the jury to appreciate entirely all the circumstances of the murder. During my practice in the courts, extending for over 20 years, I have seen very many similar cases, when a murder was committed in a state of unconsciousness. As J have not examined the accused I-cannot tell whether such a condition did exist in this casa. But I feel sure that such an-examination might have lifted the veil from the mystery- For that reason ' there exists, besides the grounds for a reprieve mentioned in the article, a still more important one, viz., the lack of psychological examination, although the accused might have been in a state of unconsciousness.

I am, ete., A. Bary.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account