Decision in Action for Recovery of Premises and Damages for Trespass In the U; S. Court for China on Saturday his Honour Judge Lobingier gave judgment in the action by Mr. J. B. Taylor against the Asiatic Motor, Inc., which had reference to the possession of ground in Astor Road on which garage is being erected.
Mr. F, J. -Schubl appeared for plaintiff and Mr. R. 8. Haskell for defendant.
His Honour's judgment was as This is an action for trespass upon, and dispossession of plaintiff, from certain premises in Shanghai. Both parties claim through John 'A. Raynes to whom on August 1, 1923, the Shanghai Land Investment Ca., Ld., owner of the premises, gave the ollowing instrument.
We beg to confirm the arrangements made whereby we rent to you for a period of 17 months, viz, from August 1, 1923, to December 31, 1924, at a monthly rental of Ts. 150 the vacant site on which were
Road, formerly the premises No, 1/2 Astor On August 13, Mr, Raynes wrote. plaintiff:—I hereby confirm that I have sublet to you the vacant site known as No. 1/2 Astor Road and now agreed to be leased to me by the Shanghai Land Investment Ca., Ld., at the same rent and upon the same terms as they have leased this site to me.
In the event of my obtaining renewal of this lease;.you are to have the benefit of it.
It. is understood and agreed be~ tween us that in consideration of this arrangement I am to receive 10 per cent. of the profit at your garage upon the site in Astor Road.
The day following he wrote the owners:—Regarding your confirmation of m lease of the vacant corner, I than you very much, but if I remember rightly "in my conversation with Mr. Peebles, we agreed that, as we were to put up the building, the rent was not to begin until we are ready to begin operations.
he plans are to pass the Council on Thursday and we will then be in a position to commence work, However I will take this up immediately with you upon my return which will be in two weeks, A copy of this last communication appears to have been delivered to the plaintiff on the same day (August 14) as the preceding one. Which was delivered first is not clear, nor. does seem to us material, since, by the communication to him, plaintiff was given the same terms as his -lessor, and it is undisputed that the latter's request in his letter of August 14 to the effect that "rent was not to begin until we are ready to begin operations," was granted.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.