His Honour said that he did not presume to pass on' which government wag meant by the Treaty. It seemed to him that the question of one duly authorize ed to purchase was similar to the law on the sale of liquor to minors. The burden of proof lay upon the defendant to show that the person sold to was over age; otherwise he would be adjudged guilty upon proof. He must make it peculiarly within his knowledge" and the law assumed such, Further argument followed between counsel and Judge Lobingier withheld his ruling on the point raised until 10 o'clock next morning.
Opening of the Case for the Defence At the resumed hearing in the U. S. Cowé on Wednesday, Judge Lobingier overruled the motion of the defence introduced on Tuesday afternoon, asking for a dismissal of the Charge. he case for the de fence was accordingly opened, Judge Lobingier's written comments on the motion to dismiss are appended at the end of the report of the day's proceedings. At yesterday's hearing Mr. L. -G. Husar and.Mr. Stirling Fessenden appeared for the Government and Mr. ©. S. Franklin and Mr. Paul Faison for the accused.
The first three witnesses for the defence were Mr. and Mrs. J. W. and Miss Anna Crofoot, all three of whom had attended the birthday tiffin given in honour of Mrs. Kearny on March 31. The evidence of these witnesses was more or less in opposition to that of Mayer and Roth, who had stated toasts were drunk and conferences hold in a small room styled the office. Mr. Franklin directed most of' his questions to show that previous statements with regard to these features were not so. Mr. Crofoot stated that he had let'the house to Kearny some time in February, that he as a missionary had transacted the business for one who had gone home. At the tiffin there had been about 10 present. According to his statements there was a party of Chinese eating in the study (office). He did not sce any conference there, and as far as he could remember there had been no toasts drunk at the table.
Mrs. Crofoot made similar remarks in her direct examination and added that Mr. Franklin had left the table to keep an appointment, as he said, with his wife, before the majority of those seated_arose.
Mr, Husar—What in particular called your attention to Mr. Franklin's departure?—He was a stranger.
Mr. Husar—You do not rem®mber for certain whether there were any toasts drunk or not?—I do not know for sure.
Mr. Husar—You can be certain at the other end there might have been toasts proposed, surely?—There may have been.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.