The Archive · 1923

The Motion to Dismiss

Judge Lobingier's Ruling

Judge Lobingier's ruling on the motion to dismiss the charge set forth the following At the close of ths prosecution's evidence the defendant's counsel presented an oral motion to dismiss on the ground that the prosecution had failed to negative the exceptions recited in the Treaty and particularly the exception of "gale to Chinese duly authorized to pwrehase them." In support of their contention, defendant's counsel relies upon a work citing four decisions, all from State courts, and constituting but an insignificant portion of the total number of decisions on the subject. The work in question mentions but one exception to the rule announced—i.e., where the facts constituting the xeeption in the statute are peculiarly within the knowledge of defendant. That exception has been recognized and applied by this Court. But. there is another qualification, quite as important, which the work cited fails to notice, viz, as stated by our Suprems Court.

When the exception or proviso is in a subsequent substantive clause. the case contemplated in the enacting or general clause may be fully stated without negativing the exception or proviso, as a prima facie case is stated, and it is for the party for whom matter of excuse is furnished by the statute or contract to bring it forward in his defence.'?

Thus under a statute prohibiting the importation of intoxicating liquors. into Alaska "except for medicinal, mechanical and scien-. tific purposes" it was held that the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account