The Archive · 1936

MUNICIPAL MODESTY

Aprit 24.

In entering upon its duties the new Shanghai Municipal Council must be struck by the flattering. expectations entertained in its behalf. The old hands, no doubt, will tell their new colleagues that visions of completing the year amid a torrent of bouquets thrown at] them at the next Annual Meeting of the Ratepayers may pleasantly mitigate the rigours of committee work, but they will probably remain. visions and nothing more. 'The atmosphere is peaceful, after a quite exciting succession of controversial storms. 'The Council will do less than justice to itself if it be lulled into a false sense of security on that account. The voice of the' critic is still heard in the land and will take power to add to its numbers as the months pass and the irrepressible sense of grievance asserts traditional influence over [pen and lung. Much criticism arises from human petulance excessively' developed, maybe, in this curious! conglomeration of nations and tastes. Other criticism would not! raise even a single angry word if endowed with knowledge of facts which, for various reasons, are hid from the public mind. The Council is too modest and hence it frequently {fails to get credit for achievements which thoroughly deserve applause. On occasions, out of the same sense modesty, it allows the impression be created of having been spurred to some good deed by outside pressure. 'There is also a tendency to forget that Shanghai is a trinity of which the Settlement is only a part. The other two parts are controlled—by municipal the combined effects of financial' administrations which, however! dissolved. admirable, are not free from detects but which, owing to a variety of circumstance, are singularly imjune from public attack.

So the professional _mentor of City Fathers—and what self-res-eeling city fails to produce such an oddily—Ands his peculiar habits best indulged by concentration on. the faults and shortcomings of the! Municipal Council. He. gets poor, satisfaction if he casts his eyes to Kiangwan or Avenue These conditions have to be accepted and the Municipal Council cannot afford to dismiss them with a general imprecation on the injustice of the world's arrangements or on the wickedness of the destiny {0 which it has been' unkindly called by the grace of the Land Regulations and the Shanghai Mind combined. As practical men the Councillors have to face the situation and deal with it as best they can. If the other two municipal bodies can exploit the secretiveness available to them in their special circumstances, it is clear that the Council does itself harm by attempting feebly imitate them, For criticism of the Council is not secretive but shouts itself hoarse from the housetops. The Council should therefore come out into the open—with loudspeakers if necessary. As it usually has, so this journal believes, a per~ fectly good case it should not lose in' the contest. Statements have been issued to show that economy is the: watchword of the Council. The truth of that contention appears Pia the annual ancial returns, but even the most erudite Controller cannot make financial returns do more than perform arithmetical functions, It requires careful ex-Position to make them eloquent. The casual remark—heard the other day in one of the Council's corridors—that retrenchment had reached the point of cutting office pencils in half, threw more vivid light on the subject than pages of statistics.

'The other day an excellent report outlined three Councillors' cone sidered views on the possibilities effecting economy in the working, of the Fire Brigade. Judging from the reactions in the press, that report should have been issued with some authoritative exposition of its significance. For some people urged that its recommendations would deprive the Settlement of proper protection against fire; others! drew the jovial deduction that since! tone department could "cough up" $200,000 without turning the proverbial hair, how about making. some of the ' others imitate its: inspiring example? These criticisms may be labelled wrong-headed but that does not really dispose of them. They simply show that, taking the: Police Department as a case in point, the Council has not placed at the disposal of the public suMcient information to establish the exact relation of departmental finance to the Ratepayers' present plight, having regard, of course, to the paramount needs' of preserving Jaw and order. Similarly it might be asked if the Public Health Department's resources have been' husbanded on the same principles.) 'The Council has, it may be guessed, splendid material for answering! such questions satisfactorily. 'The mere issue of monthly repens does not constitute this material, as those documents, for all their' intrinsic merit, do not really expound depart mental usefulness, officials being properly modest on their own work, Finally the Council, in meeting the fruitful suggestions of bodies interested in public affairs and civie well-doing,.scems often to attach undue importance to the fact that! the same issues were raised in the: dim past and were negligently shelved without. anyone being a bit the worse. Or, having been! badgered into some kind of action, it conceals the steps which had] already been taken to make that action possible and thus it is foreed complaisantly into the position having been stirred up by what may really have been an ill-informed and misdirected enthusiasm, Perhaps the new Council will avoid these pitfalls if it determines to lay its good deeds bare more systematically and more promptly before the public gaze. It is not too much to say that if it could apply to its activities generally the genius which managed to secure the retention of the Orchestra without hardly a single murmur at the Ratepayers' meeting, it would find many of its difficulties}

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account