The Archive · 1935

Companies' Ordinances

All company directors should have a working knowledge of the Hongkong Companies Ordinances, and not Leave it to the Registrar of Companies to draw their attention fo these things," said Mr. Victor Priestwood, when, on behalf of the Registrar of Companies, he opposed an application in H. 'M. Supreme Court on Tuesday, Nov. 19, by The Jowellers Ca, Ltd, for an extension fof time In which 16 file the return of fan allotment of shares, Mr. 'A. Reeks appeared on behalf fof the petitioners, and Mr. John 'MeNelll Watched the case on' behalf of Mr, F-R. Gabbott, formerly Alrector of the company.

Counsel for the company also asked that the directors and officials of the company be absolved from penalties, but Judge P. Grant Jones said that he wag not ready to entertain that] part of the application.

Opening his case, Mr. Reeks said that the motion before his Lordship was for an extension of time for the company to file with the Registrar of Companies particulars of two contracts made for the allotment of shares for a consideration other than. cash, together with the return of an allotment of shares. An affidavit signed by Mr, H. M, Gregory, a dit~ actor of the company, was then read, in which Mr. Gregory stated that he was ignorant of the requirements of the Ordinances, and had failed to Mle the return of the allotment of shares through inadvertence. Attach ed to Mr. Gregory's aMidavit was an. exhibit covering a document sent in. May last to the Registrar purporting to be the minutes of a statutory meeting, and which detailed the) allotment of shares.

Quoting from the case In Re Jack~ son & Ca, (1800 1 CH. 348), Mr. Reeks Sold that it had been held that inadvertence" covered ignorance, of the requirements of a statute. "No tone in Shanghai can buy a copy of the Ordinances, "he said, "I can tell you that from my own knowledge snd have brought the matter up afore the Bar Association."

'At this point, he was interrupted ty his Lordship, who said that he' hhed just come across the legal definttion' of "knowingly," which had caused a certain amount of diftcults the Police Covrt case on Monday against Messrs. H. M, Gregory and BR, Gabott. Quoting from the case of Burton v. Bevan (1908 2 CH, 240) he, said "knowingly" was apparently "contravenente with knowledge of the facts."

Dealing with his motion to absolve! the company's officers from the penalties to which they were liable, Mr. Reeks satd that under the terms of Hongkong Ordinances his clients subject to a fine of $500 for day over the allotted time given them in which to file the returns.

'He submitted that it was never the' intention of the legislature to inflict these fines merely for the purpose of collecting revenue, but that they had been put there in order to "keep men. straight" He said that in this instance, apart from the amdavit, there was extraneous evidence in the form of a document which had been sent to the Registrar of Companies in May which bore out the contention of the deponent that he was ignorant fof the requirements of the Ordinances. Where it was thus clear that party had sinned from ignorance, he submitted, it was a proper case for his Lordship to exercise his discretion and grant relief from the penalties, His Lordship said that he did not} see how ho could make such an order fas there was no authority for it. As fur as he could see, the words "grant relief" merely applied to an extension of time, and were not in the slightest way concerned with the absolution from penalties. The practice of granting such an order was probably, due toan "innovation which came into being by the subtlety of the Bar on the behalf of their clients. The practice is the same in Hongkong."

"Tt has been the practice of the Registrar of Companies not to raise any objections," said Mr, Priestwood, fon behalf of the Registrar, "but T oppose the extension in this case and also, the absolution from all penalties." Companies were incor: porated in order that the public might trade without jeopardizing its pocket, and the companies had certain duties towards the public and the Registrar of. companies. He submitted that if any order granting the extension of Uin.e were made, it should be coupled vith an order definitely stating that the directors and officers were not absolved from any penalties they might be subject to.

Engli, "as ammieus curie Uf he bed MeNelll, as amiens curie df he had anything to say on the two cases of!

Burton v. Bevan and In Re Jackson, hich appeared at fest sight to be conflict. Mr. MeNelll suggested! that the two cases were distingulshable because the former decision dealt with a section which: did ist excuse lability on the ground of inadvertence and it was. therefore held that "ignorance of the law was no excuse," whereas the latter case referred to a section which provided' that "ignorance of the law was excuse," and merely decided that ignorance of the law fell within the term "inadvertence."

Being satisfied that it did, his Lov ship, giving Judgment, said:

Tam inclined to, and will, grant tan order that the time be extended for seven days from to-day, and 1 am "adding—possibly obiter—dicta fat it appears to me that this means "Under Section 44 (2) of the Commies Ordinances, the company shall within eight weeks after allotment deliver to the Registrar of Companies for registration the proscribed par-Hiculars of allotment and any contract for allotment for consideration other than cash, Regarding the period of eight weeks, it appears to me that the extension begins at the end of those eight weeks. An extension of the eight weeks by seven days therefore means that the intervening per-fod is not covered by the extension and therefore no relief is granted by the extension for the period which intervenes between the end of the eight weeks and the date on which the order is made." 5 He accordingly made an order for: the extension of the period for filing the returns for seven days from November 19,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account