The Archive · 1923

The Agitator in India

Nov. 9.

Ly writing last Tuesday of the Kenya decision we showed that the agitation in India was effect, if not intention, to compel white settlers to admit the Indians in the colony to a political equality with themselves which none of their fellow natives in India would dream of according them. That fact, firmly rooted in the iron divisions of caste, is so vital in its bearing on the Indian demand for self-government that readers may well be interested in the warnings given by Sir Patrick Fagan, K.C.1.£., in the September ''Nineteenth Century.'' The writer has had_a distinguished career in the Indian Civil Service; he writes with sympathy of the people whom he has helped to govern and maintain in peace and prosperity; and he tells us that he fully accepts the policy announced by the Secretary of State for India on August 20, 1917, namely, "'the gradual development of self-governing institutions in India with a. view to the progressive realization of responsible government in that country as an integral part of the British Empire."' But sentiment, which is just now the peculiar affliction of Western politicians regarding the East,- and always the more virulent the less their knowledge, does not blind Sir Patrick to hard facts.

He lays emphasis on three important misunderstandings, to one of which the above enunciation of policy was due. Everybody remembers how the Indian Nationalists took the opportunity of the war to press for political concessions.

For some almost inexplicable reason (says Sir Patrick) an impression seems to have prevailed in high quarters in. England, 'f not in India also, that unless such concessions were speedily promised, there would be immediate and widespread trouble in the latter country. Nothing indeed could have been more contrary to the actual fact.

The peasantry of India who constitute about ninety per cent. of. its population, understood, so far as they understood anything, that their welfare was bound up with the safety of the British Empire, to whose banner they freely flocked—in contrast, it may be added, with the intelligentsia and the Babu who carefully stood aside.

This consideration brings us to the second misunderstanding noted by Sir Patrick Fagan.

It is the fashion among publicists and politicians in this country (Britain) to credit them (the vast illiterate masses of India) with the political and nationalistic aspirations of the educated. No misapprehension can be more profound, no error more far reaching in its possible consequences.

The interest of the rural population is in efficient government, whether native or alien it cares not. The result of these two misconceptions was the Mon-taku-Chelmsford Report, the product of a juncture which, as" Sir Patrick ironically remarks, "might have been dealt with more appropriately after the stress of war had been re-That this hasty and ill-considered legislation, instead of placating the agitators, was followed by even worse disaffection and outrages than before. must have been an unpleasant surprise to its authors. The explanation thereof brings us to the third misunderstanding.

The Montagu-Chelmsford Report is essentially democratic in its design, inspired with the idea that India as a whole desires democratic self-government and must have it. But Sir Patrick Fagan shows very convincingly that the agitators of India, who. are but a tiny minority, neither believe in democracy nor: desire Not only do the politically minded realize the fact that India has not even begun to be democra-tie: few, if indeed any, of them believe that democracy is either possible or desirable in India. Their intrinsic aim was to secure substantial relaxation of the galling tie of alien domination by the grant of Swaraj (Home Rule). A purely Indian autocracy working through a purely Indian bureaucracy, would be Swaraj—self-government, purged of European elements, with, however, the ~implicit but important provisoes that adequate British military force -will remain in India for the' protection of the country and that the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account