That you should permit a correspondent to characterize Nanking as "horrid" after a perfunctory ramble through Hsia-kuan, will not only be regretted by those who love the old Southern Capital; it will be resented also" How many travel-Jers, I wonder, have been deceived into regarding Hsiakuan as Nanking? Alas! that this mushroom growth, which the foreigners brought with their steamers and railways, should be confounded with the beautiful city to the southeast. One might as well attempt to see London by visiting the Millwall Docks. Has your correspondent ever wandered over the hills between the Magazine and the Han-si Men, through the oak scrub and the bamboo groves and seen the views from there? The rolling hills, the red Drum Tower, the pavilion crowned heights of Po Chi Qou and, in the background, the glories of the Mountain—purple in the shadow and gold in the sunlight. Or has he looked in the other direction along the majestic sweep of the old wall and seen the sunset across the Great River beyond the watch-towers on the Puchen Hills?
What if vegetables grow round the monuments near the Ming Tombs? Surely not in these paltry stone figures does one find the ancient grandeur of the place, rather in the tomb itself, and in the memory of the man imaginative enough to conceive the idea of making an entire mountain his grave.
What if the unsightly road to the hot springs diverts from the old highway Spirit Valley is still there. Spirit Valley with its pines, its chestnuts and its oaks; with its quiet places ''where the silence is more than all tunes," and with its wonderous autumn tints that make poets of the most hardened cynics, Does your correspondent know the stately stretch of wal] between the Shun-tze Men and the Taiping Men, for there he will find that spirit of ancient grandeur he seeks in vain in the tourist ridden spots of the guide book? There, too, he can see the daylight fading over the placid waters of the Lotus Lake and the mirrored outline of the Mountain passing with the dusk. And, with the twilight, the coming of the long regular lines of wild geese, the mallard and the teal, flighting over the wall to their might haunts in the swamps.
Does he know the winter view from the summit of Purple Mountain when the snow is on the ground or the springtime glories of its lower slopes, the peach blossoms, the lilac, the azaleas and the birds?
Can you wonder that one who has lived and loved in this most beautiful of Chinese cities should resent his criticism? Some day it may be your correspondent's
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.