The Archive · 1936

FRANCO-SOVIET PACT

Effect on Germany's Position To the Editor of the "Nosu-Cuta Dany News"

Sin—From out of the welter of reflections and views expressed by responsible (and irresponsible) {ers in regard to the political tsruggl now going on in Europe, one fact protrudes with striking larity.

The so-called "brutal gesture" by which "Germany is sid to have Violated the Treaty of Locarno is "deplored" in certain quarters without a single reference being made the juridical side of the question at stake, The reluctance to bring this angle of the subject out Into the clear light of day can only be explained by the fact that the politico-juridical evidence which. Would then be provided by the Treaty Would prove beyond all question that Germany's action Indisputably Justin The fundamental element of the Locarno Treaty is embodied In the stipulation of the agreement of the contracting parties that neither France nor Belgium nor Germany can resort to war with each other without having had recourse to the Lengue of Notions. And further= moze—and this appears to be the crucial point In dispute if the Pronco-Russian pact is related 0 the Locarno Treaty—war between the contracting parties can only be started if and after the permanent Council of the League of Nations ives its consent to such a step.

This constitutes the fundamental guarantee that none of the contracting Powers can wage an aggressive war tupan any other, It is more or less 0 security-valve against such happens Ings a8, for instance, the French inv sion of the Ruhr la 1923, 'The Franco-Russian Treaty of military alliance automatically casts away "such a security. Although reference Is made in' the main article of this instrument to convenants of the League of Nation: which superficially gives the Im= pression that the contracting parti will adhere to such decisions of the League as outlined above, this funda mental question is nulilfled additional protocol, which 1s, and must be, considered as an integral part of the Franco-Russian Treaty.

In this additional protocol plalnty stipulated that either Fran for Russia would have'to lend armet Dasistance to each other even If the League Counell—the safety-valve of the Locarno Treaty—should not come to a unanimous decision arguing military action, or, worse still, the Council does not arrive at' any decision at all, Herein Hes the point which makes the Franco-Russian pact a violation of the Treaty of Locarno, It must be remembered that the Franco-Russian Treaty was initiated by their "respective "representatives lon May 2, 1035, Since that day Germany has ropeatedly communicated notes of protest to the signatorlds of. the Locarno Treaty (France, Great Britain, Belgium and Tlaly) drawing the attention of the signatories, and leaving no doubt that under these circumstances the Frfinco-Russian Treaty must be considered " flagrant violation of the Locarno Treaty.

Likewise, no opportunity has been lost, whenever an Ambassador of the signatory powers called at the Wilhhelmstrasse, or Germany's Ambassadors had an opportunity to call on the signatories' Governments, emphasize the German protest. But all to no avall—only evasive repu were forthcoming.

Now, over a period of about ten months, the fruitless diplomatic struggle of the German side has.resulted in Its being made clear to the signatories of the Locarno Treaty that the Franco-Russian alliance fan instrument to upset the funda mental reason for the Locarno Treaty, namely {0 eliminate all danger of the possibility of an aggressive war Europe, France has similar treaties to the one with Russia with Poland and Czecho-Slovakia, But these treaties do not weaken the regular funetioning of the Council of the League of Nations in case of a war-threatening situation, Germany had never caus to protest or object there treaties, because their peace-alming character {is net to be doubted. But the Franc Russian Treaty has a different eharacter,—it destroyed the peaceable spirit of the Treaty of Locarno, The foregoing reflections are based fon indisputable politico-Juridical facts, And in view thereof it should not be so difficult to find an answer fo the question: "Was the Treaty of Locarno not already tom up when the Franco-Russian alliance was InitiaNed on May, 2, 19352."

P, Patz. Shanghai, March 14,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account