To the Ealtor of the "Naam-Cinxa Darcy News"
'Sm—As a shareholder in Rubber and other Companies, I have read the ticular dated March 6 sent out by the Shanghai Shareholders' Protection Association (In formation) with much Interest. To put it as shortly as possible the whole situation seems to me to boll down to this: he fundamental idea of the Ascoclation is to substitute collective for individual action.
'The above words, In the circular referred to, are to my mind, the mainspring of the whole Idea.' But then T have to ask myself, "What is the actual practical meaning of the phrase collective action'?" Am I convinced that, for example, the Russian Soviet principle Is a complete success? And if It has met with any success, does this mean that such success is duc to the collective activities of the Russian peoples, or is ft due to the brains of a few leaders such as Mr, Stalin? 1 feel sure that the answer is covered by the second of these alternate Teannot believe that "collective actlon™ Is practical in its literal sense: the end of the problem is that the Jeaders take charge and that true "collective action" Is nothing but 0 myth.
Now let me apply this theory to the present case, We all know and respect Mr, N.W, Hickling as a Bul-lon broker and how as a Share Bi ker: few of us know Mr.
Dut those of us who do know him re= member him only as a Bullion broker and Inter as a freight broker in Japan: none of us know either Mr. Hickling or Mr. Fearon as responsible Managers of Rubber or any other form of Companies. On the other hand many of us do know Messrs, Wattle & Ca, and Messrs, Burkill Ca, as very responsible and perleniced managers of Rubber Com-antes, Are we going to take our affairs out of the hands of experienced men, we know to place them in the hands of quite inexperienced mon whom we do not know—as Company T mean?
suppose for a moment that} something goes wrong with our Companies; a diMeult financial situation, defalcation, or any other trouble fuch og all Companies are heir fare Messrs, Hickling and Fearon going to put their hands In their pockets to make things right? Are they going to be able to bring long experience fo bear on the situation? And even supposing that they are so clever as to out-Stalin Mr, Stalin and make "collective action" a real and true success shall we really be any better off when we remember that the principals concerned are Stock Brokers whose interests are seldom it ever the same as those of shareholders?
With all due respect to Mr. Hickling I think that the answer is in. the negative; and fo put it quite bluntly Lam suMelently old-fashioned to pre-for the devil I know to the devil don't know. Personally 1 become a member of the Shareholders Protection Association as at present constituted, and T take leave to doubt that any such Association could bbe satisfactorily organized in a small community such as ig represented by the foreign community of Shang Shanghai, Mar, 12.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.