The Archive · 1929

The Agreement at Nikolsk

Dec. 6, The "North-China Daily News" certainly cannot be accused of much affection for the Soviet Government. So it may feel free to express' the opinion that Russia's reply to the Powers' representations about the quarrel with China is exactly" what should have been expected; Washington in particular, which has always pointedly ignored the Soviet, has little cause to be dat Moscow's tart mes-The fact is that the Powers, finding themselves in a. quandary, acted with the usual clumsiness which awaits people who shy away from the proper course, They disliked the idea of telling China that, unless she was prepared to come into court with clean hands, they could do nothing for her, and so fell back us adjurations to both dis-put ants, which must have annoy-Nanking intensely and gave Moscow a chance which it may be'said to have been waiting for for years. We have never concealed our opinion, which of course is only that of all onlookers, that China, having had ain excellent case against Russia, spoilt it by forcible occupation the railway, She gave Russia a technical advantage of which the latter has made the fullest use; and when appealed to by the Powers to remember her obligations under the Kellogg Pact Russia had an easy reply make. The only Foreign Office among "the Big Five" which kept its head was that of Japan, which is'thus saved from cutting the poor figure presented by its colleagues.

The incident may help to d the nations' eyes as to the ess tial hollowness of the, Kellogg Pact. For example,' Russia protests that she at least has never violated the Pact and throughout the quarrel with China has acted only. in self defence. As we said the other Gay, we may be morally _convinced that she is merely talking the usual Bolshevik language, but who is to prove it? She also on very strong ground in pointing out that the Pact contains nothing to give to any State or group of States the functions of "Pact Protector."

In fact, all that its, signatories do isto declare "that they solemnly condemn recourse to war, renounce it as an.instrument of national policy, and agree that all disputes shall be settled by peaceful means, There is a° preamble which enjoins "that any signatory which should seek to promote' it

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account