The Archive · 1929

Court of Consuls

SEQUEL TO BARRICADING THE] "WHEEL"

Koo Za-2n (Khoo Chi-ping) was plaintiff on December 3 in the Court of Consuls, before Messrs. E. $. Cunningham, Consul-General for the United States and Senior Consul (presiding), C. F. Garstin, H.M. acting Consul-General, and M. Shigemitsu, H. 1. J. 3. Consul-General, in an'action brought Jagainst the Shanghai Municipal Council, Plaintiff claimed $2,000 for Jdamages alleged to have been caused Jas a result of an unlawful trespass yy members of the Shanghai Municipal Police at the time they] barricaded "The Wheel" at 151

Bubbling Well Road on May 25 last.

Counsel appearing were Mr. Maitland for plaintiff and Mr. G. H. Wright for the Council.

Outlining the case, Mr. Maitland said that it was one for damages} for alleged trespass by the police. Tt was alleged that the police, when raiding an alleged gambling house at 151¢ Bubbling Well Road on May 25 last, climbed on to the roof of, plaintiffs house at 1003 Medhurst} Road, Mr. Wright pointed out that the place had never been raided by the police though the police would have liked to have done so, Tantamount to a Raid tone and had lived in Shanghai. for many years. A report was made to Bubbling Well police station and later to the Council. On July 8, a letter was received from the mut cipal secretary admitting that member of the police had clambered on the roof and offering, without Prejudice, to repair the roof but refusing to admit claims for monetary damages. The extraordinary part of the whole thing was that, in their answer now, the Council denied the allegation.

'Mr, Wright denied that the action' of the police was tantamount to un-_ Iaweful trespass and said that the} police had every right to do what} they did.

Plaintiff said that, at about 1 a.m. jon May 26, he heard the noise of tramping outside his house so he peered out of a window and saw three foreign and-one Chinese policemen in uniform. He did not} recognize any of them. He dared not put on the light or go outside, fearing that robbers were about. His nephew's wife suffered the jereatest shock. She was pregnant Jat the time and even at the present time she was not feeling well. She} eave birth to a child on June 8.

On Roof More than an Hour Witness sat silently in the darkness and he heard noises on the roof, [though he did not know what was going on there. He saw pistols, The tiles of the roof had been damaged and a barricade had been placed there and it was there still. The Mr, Maitland replied that it was tantamount to a raid because barr Jeades were put up and people were prevented from going in. Nevertheless, police clambered over the roof of plaintiff's house without permission and broke the tiles, The inmates, including a number of dren, were greatly terrified shocked. The police took the la into their own hands and acted like hooligans because they were s0 zealous in their attempts to stop a properly conducted gambling house. Plaintiff's family was a law-abiding

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account