The Archive · 1937

The New China

April 26.

Last week two young Chinese oMlcials of recognized authority and high intelligence made important statements on the progress of building up the new China as a coherent national entity. Dr, Hsia, a Member of the Legislative Yuan and a competent constitu tional lawyer, has contributed to the: series of bulletins issued by the: Council of International Affairs, Nanking, a brief explanatory commentary on the Draft Constitution of the Republic of China, Broadcasting from Nanking's powerful station, Mr. Han Lih-wu, Member of the Board of Trustees for the Admini stration of the Indemnity Fund remitted by the British Government, outlined the efforts of the Government to bring about the reform of the civil service In China. Neither! of these expositions on subjects! closely inter-connected and vital to the future development of the country, has pretended that actualities tallied with the principles governing the respective schemes with which they dealt, Dr. Hsia, in chronologically tracing the drafting of the Constitution from the very] inception of the Republic, took care to draw discreet attention to the so-called "transitory provisions' which, in imitation of Germany and. the Trish Free State practically, suspend the Constitution-to-be by! permitting the Central Government to retain overriding powers in supersession of the democratic} system embodied in the Draft, So, it the People's Congress which is to be assembled next November approves that draft, there is still contemplated another form of the period of tutelage in order to prevent too violent a transition from the, present one-party autocracy to full responsible government. "Among the provisions thus subjected to virtual suspension are those _for the election of the Legislative Yuan. the organization of the Examination Yuan and the organization of the, Censor or Control Yuan. Mr, Han Lih-wu, dealing with the Examination Yuan under which the civil service Is theoretically formed! and manned says "it can be considered only a beginning and vastly more needs to be done."

These reservations have their importance but it should not be argued that they necessarily imply' an intention to evade the responsibilities prescribed by the ae ceptance of reform. Dr. Hsia's able} survey of the numerous attempts] made to ae 'a constitution shows} how disappointment and failure] Persistently intruded, but it also shows that, at each renewal of the effort new ground had been made. Under the Empire a Commission appointed in 1905 travelled and] studied the problem in many countries and finally recommended the constitutional gov-'The idea was favoured.

"in principle" by the Empress Do-a 1908 the Principles of Constitution"—based on the Japanese system, but giving the Emperor "even more unlimited") powers—was promulgated with preparatory period of ten years attached to it. Agitation against this! proposed probation which was considered to be too long added fuel to the revolutionary flame. The hasty promulgation in 1911 of the "Nineteen Articles" renouncing all the Emperor's powers under the proposed Constitution, except that article which declared that he was \ered and inviolable" did not] save the Empire. The "Ninetcen Articles" were ten years too late, in the opinion of Manchu writers, quoted by Dr. Hsia. In the early, days of the Republican regime, between 1912 and 1925 there were! several attempts ut constitution-making: the Temple of Heaven draft which passed the Drafting! Committee in October 1913, but) failed to secure promulgation, the $F] Peking New Parliament Draft, adopted by its Committee in August 1919—never brought before Parliament—the Tsao Kun Federal Constitution, promulgated on October 10, 1923, but "never in operation and always considered illegal because of the manner in which it was brought into being," and the draft produced on December 12, 1925 under the regime of Tuan Chi-ju but never considered by parliament for there was no such body available. Dr, Hsia also mentions. the abortive attempt under the Military Government set up in the South in 1917. The drafting committee met on September 28, 1918, but it suspended work without producing a draft after "continuous disagree ment", sixteen months later. The present National Government works under an Organic Law first pro-. mulgated in Canton on July 1, 1925, and subjected to revision and expansion on March 10, 1927, Feb. 4, 1928, Oct. 3, 1928" (Five-Power system introduced) Nov. 17, 1930, June 14, 1931, Dee. 26, 1931, and Dee. 26, 1932—seven times in all. The proposal for a provisional constitution for the period of political tutelage was made by General Chiang Kai-shek in 1930. The preliminary draft prepared by Dr. Wang Chung-hui, now Minister of Foreign Affairs, was promulgated on June 1, 1931. In Dee, 1932 Dr.

Sun Fo advocated the preparation of a permanent constitution. In January 1933, as President of the Legislative Yuan he appointed a drafting committee and six months later Dr. John C. H. Wu, the vice-chairman, as the result of one month's lightning study, produced what is now known as the John Wa draft to give the Committee something to work on and to gauge the feeling of public opinion. Published in June 1933, this Draft formed the basis of the Preliminary Draft which, completed on Nov. 16, was! submitted to the Constitution Drafting Committee. This body produced what was called the First Draft on Feb, 23, 1934 and then dissolved to be replaced by a larger Committee which studied criticisms of the First Draft and revised it accordingly—"The Revised First Draft Fof July 9, 1934". The Legislative Yuan then came into the picture and on™ Oct. 16, 1934. After various. discussions this gave way to the Legislative Yuan Revised Draft adopted by the Yuan on Oct. 25, 1035 which running successively the gauntlet of the various organs of the Kuomintang became -transformed into the Final Draft known officially ax the Draft Constitution of the Republic of China adopted and published by the National Government.on May 5, 1936 and to be! submitted to the People's Congress for formal adoption and enactment! next November, as at present arranged.

Dr. Hsia has done well to trace the laborious processes discussion, revision and amendment} to which the framing of a written Constitution has to be subjected. Mr. Han Lih-wu, similarly, had emphasize that the creation of a permanent civil service must take considerable time. Even if the People's Congress approve the Con~ stitution it will not be working at full blast until the time has come for the removal of the "transitory provisions." The need for proceed Fig cautiously should not be allowed to obscure the urgency of ensuring progress, for as time passes impatience develops. The endowment of the Examination and Control Yuans with their full powers seems to be a natural way of approach to} conditions facilitating the eventual, working of the permanent Constitution. Mr. Han Lih-wu rightly applauded the recent observance of the civil service principle! by making the staffs of the ministries Independent of the changes at the head of those ministries. That 'a good beginning but only a beginning. At the present stage it is Obviously necessary for the Government to make specialist and] other appointments without paying] strict regard to the civil service method, but it is highly desirable that recruitment should be based! on some approved and recognized

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account