The Archive · 1937

Not Fully Democratic

It was, however, held by the Homo. Government that' neither India nor Burma was yet Int for the full democratic sysiom of Government under which the Legislature has comnplote control over the Executive, and that a certain amount of power must bbe reserved in the hands'of the Bxecutive, to be exercised by the Governor, 'This is provided for in. the so-called safeguards which have given rise to so much bitter controversy. 'The Acts of Parliament" do noi explain these safozuards quite "as clearly a8 they might, and itu necessary to turn to the' Governor's Instrument of Instructions to understand the system properly.

Excluded areas is a term which probably means nothing to these Unfamiliar with India and Burma. At every step in constitutional advance these countries there have been certain areas, inhabited for the most part by primitive tribes, where' the democratic system Is 80 obviously unsuitable that it has been impossible Include them in the general form of government, and where It is impossible even to apply most of the laws of the country, and where the only possible form of government is the simplest aystem which can be devised, suitable to a people stilt in the tribal stage, with no written language of their own, and still addicted in some cases to such customs blood-feuds, slavery, head-hunting and human sacrifice, if they can practise them with a reasonable chance of not being detected.

'Of these excluded areas Burma for geographical reasons possesses more than any other part of India, but they fall' into two completely " different categories. The first is the Federated Shan States, lying to the east. of Burma proper, which really correspond to the Native States of India with this Important difference that they are British territory. Their rulers have, however, nearly as much independence as the rulers of any but the largest of the Indian States, and the Burmese system of suzerainty has been continued rather than dir-

The Governor is given two powers, to be exercised in different depart ments of Government. In some cases he is empowered to act "in his diseration," and In other cases to net "according to his individual jude mont." The distinction between these powers I briefly that in rik tors in which he acts in his diseroion he Is not bound to consult his Ministers at all, and they are not loyally entitled to advise him. "In matters in which he exercises his individual judgment he is bound to consult the Minister oF Ministers concerned in the first place, but is specially enjoined that he should not accept their advice if he considers It against the true interests of good 'The Governor of cause has the Inherent power of veto which all heads of States possess, and his assent necessary to all acts of the Lexisature just' as is the assent of the: King ili England, The peculiarity of the now Tndian Constitution ties in the fact that whereas in England the: Grown has a theoretical right to veto any det of the Legislature, a right which has inthe course" of time fallen so much Into disuse that in practice it no longer exists, in India and Burma there are special subjects Inid down in which it is the definite duty of the head of the Executive to intervene in certain circumstances.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account