The Archive · 1923

Diplomats Standing Together

The diplomatic attitude is an entirely different one but may prove to be equally embarrassing. Since the Lincheng affair there has been a much stronger _tendency within the Legation Quarter towards mutual ce-operation for the preservation of individual rights and interests when these are threatened by the Chinese. This new tendency has prompted the Legations to discover at rather a late date that the Boxer Indemnity was a single indemnity paid to a@ coalition of Powers who agreed among themselves how this lump sum was to be divided and how the debt was to be served; and that all are therefore equally interested in seeing that the total indemnity be collected and that no portion of it be withheld, unless that portion is voluntarily relinquished by the Power or Powers concerned.

They therefore argue that even the German indemnity was not forfeit until Germany formally relinquished her claim upon it in a formal treaty with China, that the Austrian indemnity is not cancelled but only suspended pending a Sino-Austrian treaty in which Austria shall relinquish her claim upon her portion and that the Russian indemnity is by no means cancelled but is an accumulating fund, supposedly held in trust by the Chinese Government for a future Russian Government pending recognition and adjustment. From this point of view the Protocol Powers are therefore custodians of this accumulating fund, since it constitutes a part of the Lump sum of the indemnity assigned to them by China for distribution among themselves and are therefore in a@ position to protest against the use of any portion of the Russian indemnity for the service of other loans as though it were a misappropriation.

If one adopts this point of view, which the Legations now seem inclined to adopt since they are getting together to support the French Government in its dispute with China over the gold Trance question, it is clear that The Legations are in duty bound to protest airist a fresh hypothecation of the Russian indemnity for whatever purpose and to confess that their failure ta protest against the issue of the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account