The Archive · 1923

Identifying an Egg

Basket of 72 Provides a Police Court Problem Mr. G. W. King had before him on Wednesday a Sikh watchman named Ojager Singh, who was charged with the theft of a basket of eggs, worth $2, the property of Messrs. Behr & Matthew, cold storage merchants and exporters, of Yangaszepoo Road, Mr. E. T. Maitland conducted the prosecution, and Mr. J. G. Priestwood was for the defence, The evidence for the prosecution was that a number of eggs were missed from baskets in complainant's godown, and that most of the eggs in one basket beneath an open window were smashed. [nvestigations made by Det.-SEe. Douglas showed that entrance to the godown had been gained through an unfastened window near the fire escape, and that there was a foot print on the windows ill showing a foreign rubber heel. The accused, who the No. 1 watchman at the place, was found to be wearing similar rutaer heels, but the detective would not vouch that the impression corresponded exactly with the pattern worn by accused.

A basket of eggs was found at the house of another watchman, known to the accused, but Ojager denied that he had taken *them there or that he was at the house on the day following the theft. A witness who stated that he saw accused there at 8 o'clock in the morning afterwards withdrew this statement.

As to the identify of the eggs, Mr. Perry, representing the firm, swore that the eggs produced were from a certain district from which his company obtained supplies but which, for business reasons, he would not name, and he added that it was unlikely they could be obtained at other places in Shanghai.

The defence was a complete denial of the charge, and Mr. Priestwood urged that the deduction of the detective with regard to the reiber heel could not be. depended upon, while the evidence of even an expert as to the identity of an egg should be accepted with reserve.

After a very careful thearjng, Mr. King discharged the accused. finding that the prosecution bat not proved their case "up to the hilt," as required by English law, and that, if such a case went before a jury, they would give the accused what was usually but wrongly described as "the benefit of the doubt."

There was a charge against another watchman, Lishman Singn, of having received the eggs knowing them to have been stolen, and the hearing of this was adjourned until this morning.

A Product of Doubtful Identity have been stolen from the odor The basket of eggs alleged to

of Messrs. Behr & Matthew in

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account